[en] The Prancing Pony > The Lord of the Rings

The Hobbit Trilogy

<< < (52/71) > >>

Ealendril der Dunkle:

--- Zitat ---I really regret that PJ left such beautifull and meaningfull scenes full of wisdom and dramtic moments out for showing like more Alfrid and Legolas !
--- Ende Zitat ---
Yes, you are right. This is just a beautiful scene. Personally i think its one of the best scenes in the movies. Sadly....

LordDainIronfoot:
Absolutely agree!
The Acorn Scene and the Gems Scene are deffinetely one of the highlights of the Hobbit Trilogy if not one of the best everr ! :) They deserved a place there more than most EE scenes included! :(

I just can't think why PJ delted them from the EE!  :(

ThorinsNemesis:
^^Ealendril, I completely agree with you, that scene could have been the best scene of BOTFA  :(.
^No problem, LordDain, I always look for this kind of scenes in the Hobbit anyway  ;)
About the coronation of Dain, I agree - I was imagining all the main characters standing near the Throne of Erebor, then Dain comes in, wearing the King's robes, sits on the Throne, and Balin coronates him - abd then the 'Long live the King!' part. I mean, his coronation scene during the funeral was nice, but imo not enough  8-|
And if we start on unfinished plots, there are quite some -
1.What is Sauron's plan and why does he want Smaug and Erebor? - this was easily fixable - the palantir vision scene that should have been in DOS could have explained everything clearly without leaving the people wondering.
2.Why didn't they show at least a few seconds-scene of Smaug destroying the Windlance, after all the build-up it got neglected? - only a few seconds, Smaug could see the Windlance and destroy it, and after Bard sees it destroyed, he goes to the Belltower.
3.I am very grateful that PJ showed us a short glimpse of the Kingdom of Angmar, I like that realm. But he could have explained it more to the casual viewer; for example, when Gandalf is talking about Angmar with Bard and Thranduil, he could explain the story of Angmar to Bard, and then PJ could show a flashback showing its history, the war with Arnor, and most importantly - that flashback could have been an opportunity to explain the story of Thranduil's dead wife.
Don't get me wrong, I love the Hobbit movies - actually they are my favorite movies ever!  xD
But, maybe if the stories I mentioned had been more developed, the movies could have been so much better.  :(

Adrigabbro:
I'm quite disappointed by this extended edition...  :(
What did we get? 20 minutes of ... some ridiculous scenes (Alfrid's scene is a shame, not to mention Legolas'), "more" Smaug and Beorn (c'mon, both barely got 10 additional seconds on screen), really weird concepts (that troll with no foot and no arm... wtf can't unsee it and the one in Alfrid scene isn't better; other trolls/halftrolls are just ok, no more) and a way too short funeral/coronation scene.
Still, I liked the battle between dwarves and elves, some new battle scenes and the battlewagon scene, even if it's far from perfect. The only close to perfect scene is the dicussion between Bofur and Bilbo: I love that one. Too bad they deleted scenes like the one you guys mentioned...

Gandalf The Gray:
you and me both mate im so disappointed by the EE and i saw some deleted scenes that i was thinking they are going to appear in the movie but they did not

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete