That was really nice game, I watched that replay without fast forward option.
Simple proof that Mordor is strongest in late game.
Any way, in my opinion that Erebor player was best. Maybe lack of siege weapons from Erebor was reason of defeat for dwarves. Simple in replay they tried to counter attack Mordor, but they couldn't do anything near that Tol-in-Gaurhoth, they tried to destroy that building but no success. Because of that I think they needed siege weapons in that situation. That was breaking point in this match in my opinion.
Again I must say, very nice replay in general Adrigabbro!
Keep uploading similar stuff.