[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Rohan Suggestions

Changes for Royal Guard and Archers, Poll

<< < (4/6) > >>

Walküre:
I like very much this idea.

It would be a more valuable way to widen the role of the Rohan's Royal Guard, and focus on its high-skilled members, who would be able to evenly fight on foot or to ride a horse, as true Guardians of the Horse Lords' King  ;)

Elite KryPtik:

--- Zitat von: Adrigabbro am 22. Aug 2015, 10:02 ---I answered no because I don't like the idea of having 6 same heroic battalions. For instance can you picture 6 battalions with bow behind your army? That's no rohan. Even though Mordor and Gondor have (way) more, that doesn't mean Rohan should get additional heroic units.
Plus, if the team is not fond of making a summon from a level 10 hero permanent in the first place, I don't think they will like this idea better.

--- Ende Zitat ---
Sorry to break it to you Adriggabro, but right now good Rohan players don't make cavalry, and for good reason. Peasant spam with archer backup is much more reliable. Giving Rohan more Royal Guards, and ones that can dismount, would actually improve Rohan's cavalry game, and make it more feasible to get cavalry. If the player wanted to dismount them and put them behind your army, again you have to remember that they would be very vulnerable to cavalry, and that they cannot get fire arrows and so don't do as much damage as other elite archers. Additionally, while on foot they don't really have a special ability besides switch weapon, whereas while mounted they DO get a special charge ability. Finally, the reason there would be 6 battalions with this idea is because its merging 2 different heroic battalions, so it would only make sense and be fair to have 6 battalions.

Gandalf The Gray:
and rohan suppose to be the cavalry  faction with not so good the cavalry than gondor i think this is not right

Lord of Mordor:
This wouldn't be a 'merging' of units (especially considering that Hama's guard is limited to one unit with a duration timer attached), it would simply make an existing unit much more powerful by giving it a very strong new option. And while I think this might actually be a pretty good idea for the Royal Guard, it's not a very good reason to double their recruitment limit on top of that. As others have said, Rohan is not meant to be a faction that can field six heroic infantry units.

As for comparison to other factions, Mordor actually only gets their full seven heroic units once you control two outposts and two very expensive buildings, that's quite a difference from simply getting six heroic units in your basic stables. Also note that Mordor has no upgrades and very few elite units. Gondor has more than Rohan, Isengard has less, and the Dwarves have potentially more but tied to a more complicated recruitment scheme that also needs a settlement and can this be disrupted. Lorien will also have only one heroic unit, so I don't Rohan is unfairly behind here.

I'd still like to try out a mount for the Royal Guard, but not with an increased limit.

LordDainIronfoot:
As I said above I tihnk adding the Dismount Ability can be enough and the battalions can be 4 at Max and it will be rather fine I think! :)

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete