[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Discussion and Feedback

Poll: Tauriel in Edain Patch 4.2

<< < (4/10) > >>

Ealendril der Dunkle:

--- Zitat von: Tienety am  8. Okt 2015, 15:30 ---i have no problem with Tauriel in spellbook.
But maybe Tauriel can be new scout for Lorien. I really don't like Rumil and Orophin as scouts. They are just two Galadhrim with names, nothing more.  [ugly]
Tauriel, Frodo or Sam can be more interesting scouts. 8-)

--- Ende Zitat ---
Without a vote on the subject (and the poll) itself:
Personally, i dont agree on that. Orophin and Rumil have an interesting and unique system and they fit into the faction Lothlorien. Tauriel has absolutly nothing to do with Lorien, so it wouldnt fit if you can recruit her in the Lothlorien-Citadel.
Keep in mind, that Rumil and Orophin are canon and Tauriel is an invention of Peter Jackson.

CragLord:
+1 for Summoned option

Most of reasons are already mentioned, so I will try not to repeat some else.  :D
I think that this kind of implementation represents true balance between lore and movie presentation. It shouldn't be permanent because she didn't exist in Mirkwood in time of War of the Ring or Hobbit. In other hand, there is lot of people who finds her really lovely, and her movie role. So this implementation presents her in Captain's role in very nice way, and temporary duration is price which must be paid because Lore reasons. :)

LordDainIronfoot:
First of all congrats to CragLord for his new position!Good luck my friend and have fun testing and helping the Team! :)

Now on the object at hand,I must say I agree with Ea,Tauriel is not suited to be Loriens(not Mirkwood) Scout since she basically has nothign to do with Lorien in any way and al lthat is further backed up by the fact that she is non canon while Rumil and Orophin are and fit perfectly in their Role as Scouts sicne they were kinda border Guards too! :)

Tauriel should stay a Summon with her Patrol Units but may be for some Longer time and really get Weapon Switch not by Skill like Legolas! :)

I really think she is not so needed as Pemament Hero thats allmbut that has nothoing to do with me hating her or something like thatm,I actualyl like her quite a lot I like her even more than Arwen I only disliked that she had too big Role in the Movie and the whole Love Triangle idea that was forced on PJ by WB so thatteenage girls can freak out from pleasute in wacthing it XD XD  [uglybunti] [uglybunti] [uglybunti]

ThranduiltheElvenKing:
Mirkwood is in fact a SUBFACTION, not an actual independent faction.
Furthermore, its power and role in the 'geopolitics' of the War of the Ring are definitely inferior to Lothlórien's ones.

Man, therefore ... there would be great an idea to make Mirkwood as own faction. Lorien and Mirkwood are two different realms

Walküre:

--- Zitat von: ThranduiltheElvenKing am  8. Okt 2015, 18:00 ---Mirkwood is in fact a SUBFACTION, not an actual independent faction.
Furthermore, its power and role in the 'geopolitics' of the War of the Ring are definitely inferior to Lothlórien's ones.

Man, therefore ... there would be great an idea to make Mirkwood as own faction. Lorien and Mirkwood are two different realms


--- Ende Zitat ---

They are indeed two different and isolated realms in the War of the Ring.
But, we are still talking about the same Elven Kin, mainly Sindar, Nandor and Avari (Galadriel is the only exception).
Both the Lords of Lothlórien and Mirkwood (Celeborn and Thranduil) have their background in the Sindarin Royal Court of Doriath in Beleriand, during the War of the Jewels and before.

Given these elements, it won't nonetheless be possible to have a new Elven faction just for Mirkwood, due to the very Edain Mod's mechanics and structure (number of heroes, structures, spell...).
Not even the Humans have more than three factions, for now; why should the Elves, who are diminishing and leaving the World in the Late Third Age, be represented with another third faction?

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete