Dwarven Pipers

[WarOfTheRingVeteran]

Since Lórien has chanteuses, I thought the Dwarves could get something similar: The Pipers! Like this: http://media.moddb.com/cache/images/members/1/762/761504/thumb_620x2000/Iron_Hills_Piper.jpg

If Edain doesn't like the design, make your own if you want; not important.

They would have a bit different role than chanteuses; they would have the same leadership bonus when their ability is activated as the hearths on the battle wagons have. Under condition that wagons can't get hearths anymore, for balance reasons.

[LordDainIronfoot]

I had an idea bout them long time ago and even talked with few guys about it but I think Edain wil lnever like such a thing!
It is too much not Dwarven looking I guess!
Altghough it would ahve been fun to have them!

If someon shows interest I coudl share my crazy idea here too!

[korner]

If Edain doesn't like the design, make your own if you want; not important.

IF this would be implemented - how long untill at least 6 threads are opened demanding the movie design??

Since Lórien has chanteuses, I thought the Dwarves could get something similar

answer: uniqueness!
Edain tries to make every faction unique. The elven girls are unique about Lorien, so why give something similar to another faction which does not necessarily need it (from gameplay reasons)?

Under condition that wagons can't have hearths anymore, for balance reasons.

Main use of battlewaggons is hearths and banners. If you remove one - why not remove battlewaggons at all? Because they are unique...

[Skeeverboy]

Sry, but I don't like the Idea, because...

1. It is a doubling to the unique chanteuses.

2. What is the different?

They would have a different role than chanteuses; they would have the same leadership bonus when their ability is activated as the hearths on the battle wagons have.

3. The dwarvens don't need such a unit.

[LordDainIronfoot]

Agree with you guys!

And to me it really doesnt feel so Dwarvish like whole!
Although I regret PJ do not givin IHs a Horn Sound
 But I really do not see the pipers so good for the Dwarves,although the Pipe is the most traditional music instrument in my Country