I was quite wary about this minor suggestion; I mean, I was quite doubtful whether I should post it in the internal forum or here. I have elected the latter. The new spellbook is now available and so should this proposal be subjected to the public in equal manner.
Well, the kernel of all is Gil-galad's soon-to-be special ability, related to siege as the prime focus, as for the other noble commanders of such extraordinary host. Personally, gameplay-wise, I don't have anything against it and the logic of the overhaul compels one to revolve around a siege-themed concept. I have nothing to say about it. Only, what makes me unsure of the said ability is its conceptual reference:
Vilya. Not only does the mightiest of the Three Rings have little to do with offensive features (I would understand that, in a strict game-oriented context), but there are also some inconsistencies of particular note, referring to the lore which we always deem just judge and solid foundation of the Edain Mod. Vilya had in fact already been entrusted to the trustworthy government of our wise Elrond, prior to the grand battle at the Black Gate or in Mordor itself. Gil-galad knew well what would later befall and that the ultimate clash with Sauron could lead to his own definitive demise.
Furthermore, Vilya as a motive doesn't sound like a right choice, even if we solely consider gameplay. The Ring of Air is already represented and perfectly embodied by the leader of the faction, who uses its power to clothe himself with a defensive armour of winds and gusts. Having Vilya be present in another feature and in a totally different system would be too much redundant, as we're talking about a prime element for the faction, given the incredible evocative and magical potential of the artefact in the Elven lore. So, I have myself come up with what I think will be a worthy alternative, dealing with another item/artefact that won its proper place in the old tales of Middle-earth:
Aeglos.
Aeglos is the legendary spear of Gil-galad, greatly feared by his enemies and considered nearly invincible. This blade is also mentioned in the very Silmarillion and totally fits in the offensive character of the ability, meant to portray the High King's fury when he tears buildings down. A concept that is thus more appropriate for the case and that is honestly more in tune with the Last Alliance lore; that is the chapter in which Tolkien narrates the weapon's existence. It would also be another bit of the ancient times that has the chance to be explored in the game, and differentiation, combined with the lore, is what the Edain Mod is all about
Aeglos, Lance of the Firmament:
The High King of the Noldor unleashes the fury of his legendary spear in the targeted area, dealing high damage to anything of wood and stone.The host of Gil-galad and Elendil had the victory, for the might of the Elves was still great in those days, and the Númenóreans were strong and tall, and terrible in their wrath. Against Aeglos the spear of Gil-galad none could stand; and the sword of Elendil filled Orcs and Men with fear, for it shone with the light of the sun and of the moon, and it was named Narsil.
J.R.R. Tolkien - The Silmarillion: Of the Rings of Power and the Third AgeIn pretty much any medieval lay and epic composition, together with the ancient mythological poems of old literature, a great hero, of whom minstrels sing, is always accompanied by his/her own weapon and the very weapon acquires its own personality/story/connotation in the narration. Especially, in whatever tale that has battle as its main focus. Tolkien is therefore no exception. And Aeglos appears briefly in the prologue of LOTR too.
Hence, what dost thou say, gentle friend of the Edain kindred?
AYE1. Walküre
2. OakenShield224
3. Julio229
4. AulëTheSmith
5. DrHouse93
6. NoldorSithLordsShipwrigh t
7. lordoflinks
8. Fredius
9. kreso
10. dkbluewizardNAY