[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Tournaments

Thanks to Everyone!

<< < (2/3) > >>

Fine:

--- Zitat von: Idrial12 am 15. Aug 2016, 11:03 ---Shouldn't at least I be in charge to choose somone who represents me in the final?

--- Ende Zitat ---

I had no part in the tournament, but this sentence stuck out to me while reading the thread. Was there no communication with the players about matters of importance like this one? What Caun said about replacing a player and then getting that player disqualified also seems a strange decision to me.

I do not think the posts in this thread should be deleted. As someone who literally just read about all this this morning I think it is important that communication is very important, even when it is done in a public way like this.

Walküre:
Elite has organised the Cup in the first place and opened this very thread. He legitimately has the right to ask Moderators to keep order and have his threads closed (even if Moderators don't need such permission anyway).

Giving constructive criticism and going too much private in complaining are two distinct things. And I have the duty to ensure that the latter option doesn't eventually degenerate in direct clashes among people. Disputes and issues of this kind ought to be solved via PMs (and this feature exactly exists to allow us to do so). Furthermore, if anyone needs to inform Moderators and even Administrators of something in particular (facts or personal opinions), you can easily do it by sending a PM too; flatly possible.

As I also have to guarantee that users do have their possibility to express themselves, I think we can find a settlement and arrange to establish a thread or a discussion in which people may give proper feedback to Elite's Cup. Bear this very carefully though: if you want to provide useful feedback (either positive or negative) publicly, you necessarily have to comply to the rules of this forum and to the reasonable customs of well-behaving. That is, angry and resentment-based remarks as the ones above won't be accepted.

Elite KryPtik:
I have already agreed on the poor organization, we shall do better in the future. We did do a schedule and had originally planned on sticking to it, but because of technical difficulties we were delayed by an hour and a half. I had been in contact with DevilsDaemon, and he had said to me everything was good, then come the day tournament everything clearly was NOT good. So that was something out of my control.

For the semi finals rescheduling, as I have already said, we planned on doing it Saturday, but were delayed by an issue IRL, which I didn't find out about until it was nearly time to start streaming Saturday, so we rescheduled for Sunday. I told everybody everywhere I could, including the official Skype Group which Idrial declined to join, as she refused to give me her skype details. Lord of Mordor even made a post about it in the news section to let people know it was delayed.

Finally, regarding Idrials match, I will repeat myself: She declined to show up. All of the other rescheduling of players matches were INVOLUNTARY on our part, due to unforseen circumstances. We never once, during the entire tournament, rescheduled a players time by choice. I told Idrial that if she didn't play we were going to get a substitute player to fill in so we could finish the tournament, and asked her to either stay and play or name a substitute, both of which she declined to do. I did the best I could with what I had available.

Now, I am really done discussing this here. This was meant to be a public thank you to the viewers for showing up, not a bickering zone to dispute the end details. If you want to talk to me over pms, go ahead, but I am now asking for DieWalkure to please delete all above posts and close the thread.

Idrial12:
STOP!
 
I could not play because I had to go to the doctor at 8 am...

DieWalküre plz just move the messages to another FeedbackThread.

This is hones feedback and obviously other players share my point of view!

Elite KryPtik:
I understand you couldn't play Idrial, but that doesn't mean that we just change the rules and wait an entire week for a single match. The alternative to a substitute player would be disqualification, and so because I tried to get a good player to fill in for you I'm being criticized. If you are going to dispute the replacement player I had available to play for you, we can go with the alternative of disqualification due to a no show for your game.

Feel free to move the replies to a different thread DieWalkure, I am done discussing this, period. If people want to lampoon me and get me banned from the forums they can go right ahead, I did the best I could at the time, and it didn't come out as I would have liked it to.

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete