28. Mär 2024, 09:18 Hallo Gast.
Willkommen Gast. Bitte einloggen oder registrieren. Haben Sie Ihre Aktivierungs E-Mail übersehen?

Einloggen mit Benutzername, Passwort und Sitzungslänge. Hierbei werden gemäß Datenschutzerklärung Benutzername und Passwort verschlüsselt für die gewählte Dauer in einem Cookie abgelegt.


Select Boards:
 
Language:
 


Autor Thema: Smaug, the Chiefest and Greatest of Calamities  (Gelesen 37467 mal)

AulëTheSmith

  • Elronds Berater
  • **
  • Beiträge: 300
Smaug, the Chiefest and Greatest of Calamities
« am: 9. Okt 2017, 02:32 »
Hello guys  :)
Under the guide of the great moderator Walküre, i managed to open this new thread which is completly devoted to Smaug The Terrible. The Misty Mountains faction is not around the corner yet, however it would be good to start the discussion about such a central figure as Smaug will be for MM.
As Walküre said to me: the sooner we start the better will be.
So, to begin with, here is my concept of Smaug as i would like to see him implemented. Feel yourself free to discuss/criticize about any detail you deem relevant. if you catch some mistake(s), please tell me and i'll correct it/them :).

P.s: graphical matters are not involved (for now) in my concept. Mainly because i have seen there are many different tastes about it in the forum. I also deem the design secondary with respect to the game mechanics and functions; even if i cannot hide the deep desire to see, one day, a movie-based model in game (classical 4 legs dragon):





SMAUG THE CHIEFEST AND GREATEST OF CALAMITIES

As a final note, i like also the "transparency" effect on the body of Smaug we have seen in the movies, such that is possible to see the light of the flames through his scales when he's preparing the next fire-attack. If it is possible, it would be cool to see a similar FX animation in game everytime he spits fire, whatever model of Smaug the team will choose.


Blazing breath (a Walküre'poem)

As the strongest wind, slashing the air,
Catastrophe, come out of his lair,
He seeks gold, the treasure inside the mountain-realm, whose gate is torn down by blazing breath,
Descending the skies, a dreadful dragon much havoc has wrought, willing to sow fire and reap death.




The core of my concept.

Initially the Greatest Calamity of Middle Earth will have a weakness against arrows while flying, but with an increasing of the armor along the path of power. Following the lore and films Smaug has an impenetrable armor, it is practically impossible to fear him with normal weapons. Since this interpretation would be unbalance in game, it is impossible to implementi it as it is.
Anyhow, the player must have (at least) more chances to survive against rains of arrows. Therefore i decided for that increasing of armor at level five. 
The dragon will have two different animation in flight and on the ground like in 3.8.1 (Drogoth+Summoned dragon).
As for the fire related abilities: i don’t think fireball and fireflies fit very well with a dragon.  These type of attack are more related to wizard, which are able to create such particular form of fire attack using magic. In particular we have these two abilities just implemented via Gandalf (Dwarves) and Saruman . I will explain better all the details below in the skill-set.

P.s: There are some parts that are denoted as Work In Progress (W.I.P.). These parts, because of lack of ideas or dissatisfaction, are still to be completed. There I need to know new ideas to fill in the gaps and/or change some particulars :).

SMAUG GAME IMPLEMENTATION

EARLY GAME: TRIBUTES SYSTEM

At the beginning of the game Smaug will be available in the Dragon Lair, with the summoning system showed below. Smaug is summoned at level 10 with the below mentioned stats.

With respect to old versions, i decided to remove from Smaug the traditional leveling up system. That's because it actually doesn't fit really well with such an ancient,experienced, huge dragon like he is. In his summon form he will appear at level 10 but with limited stats with respect to the maximum, mainly because balance reasons. Then in his permanent form he will directly gets the maximum stats. 

Summon statistic values :

  • HP : 10000.
  • No Population cost
  • Melee attack value: 400.
  • Type of melee attack: AOE.

Basic attack like fellbeast and eagles in flight, fire attack at land.

He unlocks abilites through the summoning system, and each tribute is the evolution of the tribute before so each offer can be used only once. Between one offer and the other, there will be a certain cooldown.

Level 1: "Small Treasure": at the cost of 750 resources you can temporary summon Smaug for some minutes. Smaug can now land and fly and he unlocks abilites "Incinerate" and "Dragon Breath".

Level 2: "Great Treasure": at the cost of 1500 resources you can temporary summon Smaug for some minutes. Smaug  unlocks abilites "Roar of the beast","Greediness","Impenetrable armor".

Level 3: "Immense Treasure": at the cost of 3000 resources you can temporary summon Smaug for some minutes. Smaug unlocks the abilites "My claws are spear","Wings like an hurricane", "Hypnotic Gaze" and "I'm Fire I'm Death".

Smaug cannot pick up the ring in this form.
The cost values and time-interval involved can change.


SMAUG IN THE SPELLBOOK: CENTRAL SPELL FOR MM

"Usurper"

The term "Usurper" is general and refers to the infesting nature of goblins. They take possession of places and things that once own to the enemy, rather than build and produce (which is the main characterstic of other "industrial" evil faction, such as Isengard).
I chosen Smaug as a picture for the spell, because he's the greatest of the example of the usurping nature of the faction, with the climax of Erebor ruin.
Via this spell, advanced upgrades and/or elitè units will be provided to the most important military structures of MM:

- Dragon Lairs are filled with the "Treasure Of the Golden One" (in game the treasure will be graphically visible around the Lairs), Smaug is now recruitable at the cost of 3000 resources just at level 10 with improved stats:

  • HP : 15000.
  • Population cost: 60
  • Melee attack value: 600.
  • Type of melee attack: AOE.
Basic attack like fellbeast and eagles in flight, fire attack at land.

 His initial set of ability is carried over from the tributes system. The lair give now passive leadership on drakes near it, since now they are more aggressive to defend the treasure (something like +30% of armor). 

Note: If the player don't make use of the tributing system before unlocking the central power, then he can upgrade smuag's skillset left-clicking on tribute button and then on Smaug.

If the Dragon Lair is destroyed, it drops a certain amount of resources (balancewise, equal at most to the cost of the building itself, in order to avoid extra-earnig via self-destruction of the Lair).
If the last Dragon Lair in game is shattered when Smaug is in game, the treasure of the Golden One is Lost , and Smaug has no more reasons to fight permanently on your side: immediately after the destruction, Smaug turns back in is temporary form, with a timer that has to be set properly in order to give the possibility to build again the Lair. The restoration of his treasure (via rebuilding) is the only way to stop the running out of the timer.


Influence on the other structures (W.I.P.)

I report here some ideas of the user Garlodur, feel freeto post new ideas or critiques about the implementation of the other caves  :)


  • Warg/Wolf Lair (settlement):
    Similar to Angmar's Wolf Den a small defensive point is built (perhaps producing few resources) surrounded by a few Warg/Wolf creeps. Before upgrading however it does not have the ability to recruit units. When the central spell is bought, the Lair recruits Wargs with a specialty as anti-cavalry.
  • Settlement Troll Cave (settlement):
    A simple Troll Lair with creeps that produces few resources and recruits Cave Trolls as they are currently known, useful for quick assaults on enemy buildings (performing the battering ram function). With Untamed Allegiance bought these Trolls can receive a weapon upgrade improving melee combat against units (mace/club), buildings (hammer), or cavalry/heroes (spear). Of course it also recruits the infamous Bill, Bert and Tom.
  • Giant Cave/Hideout (outpost):
    The Giants remain in this faction as long range siege weapons with high defensive capability. The upgrade unlocks a defensive boost to the Giants, making them more resistant to arrows and ranged siege. The Hideout itself provides a defensive leadership yet unspecified. I feel it should reflect Gandalf's thoughts in The Hobbit crossing the mountain passes, as he considered taking refuge in a Giant cave.

SMAUG'S SKILLSET

Smaug skill-set in flight

Rank 1 : "Landing" – as usual.

“Incinerate”(Requires "Small Treasure") – Smaug spits fire on the selected area, inflicting high damage to standard units and medium damage to siege weapons, but low damage against structures, heroes, heroic units and monsters (except fire-sensible ones like ent and mumakil).

The power is nerfed with respect to the original version, it will be something more effective against units, as a first mass-slayer area of effect ability, like for example is wizard blast for Gandalf and Saruman. The animation of course will remain the same of Drogoth. Personally i think Smaug deserves some more devasting power for the last level.

“Roar of the Beast”(Requires "Great Treasure") – the fearsome roar of the Golden one makes the enemy flee in terror.

“Impenetrable Armor (passive)”(Requires "Great Treasure") – quoting Tolkien, “my armor is like tenfold shields”. Smaug permanently gains +50% armour against arrows.

“Wings like an hurricane”(Requires "Immense Treasure") – Smaug uses his massive wings to create an air blast that knock back units in a wide radius dealing also medium damage.

“I’m fire, I’m death”(Requires "Immense Treasure") – like we seen in the scenes of BOTFA during the attack of Lake Town, Smaug sets fire on the ground while flying, burning everything in a hell of fire.

The crucial point of this last ability is the animation. The most fitting to resamble what we have seen in the movie, is the Dragon Strike attack. Supposing the power will be removed from the spellbook of MM of course. Just imagine this beautiful animation given to Smaug:


The sequence from BOTFA:


Smaug skill-set on the ground

Now the basic melee attack of Smaug is fire as in 3.8.1. Being on the ground, he will be weaker to revenge-damage of the pikes and hero-killers.
 
Rank 1 : “Flying “– as usual.

"Dragon Breath"(Requires "Small Treasure"): a fire attack very effective against gates. Smaug’s Firebreath opens Gates and even burns garrisoned units.

I simply copied the one presented so far by the team but i make it active and not passive. Same animation of the basic fire attack. Also the flames of Firedrakes from vanilla game are very good but probably is difficut to adapt such animation to a bigger model like the one of Smaug.

  “Roar of the Beast” (Requires "Great Treasure") – same as in flight.

“Greediness (passive)”(Requires "Great Treasure") – The desire of gold and treasures makes Smaug very greedy. ALL the productive buildings (both enemies and allies) in a wide area around Smaug get -30% of production.

“My Claws are Spears”(Requires "Immense Treasure") – Smaug uses his legs and claws to smash the enemy units. For 30 seconds he gets +30% armor against spearmen and he can trample the masses swatting all on his path (just think about the amazing scenes in which he enters into Erebor). It affects also cavalry-type units.

“Hypnotic Gaze”(Requires "Immense Treasure") – as the ancient fire-worms of the first age, Smaug can cast hypnotic spells using his eyes. The selected enemy hero can suffer three possible effetcs:

1) The enemy hero cannot withstand the dragon-spell and falls in an hypnotic state, Smaug takes control of him. The hero is temporary converted on your side but his ability cool-down timer are reset.

2) The magic gaze of Smaug stuns the enemy hero who temporary falls in an hypnotic state. Smaug forces the hero to reveal himself and all tell to the dragon all his plans. For 20 seconds the hero cannot move and you share the sight with all the enemy heroes. Also, as a consequence,  invisible heroes are revelated.

3) The enemy hero free himself from the dragon-spell but he's demoralized and outworn: he has -25% of attack,defence and speed for 10 seconds.

The first effect will mainly affect weak heroes like scout-heroes and, in minor way,
 also stronger heroes from 1000 to 2500 resources.
The three effect are in decreasing order of power. Apart of the esclusions indicated below, the more the hero is stronger the less will be hypnotized, so lower is the probability to fall in the hands (better to say claws  :D) of Smaug. For example, heroes like Aragorn, Gimli, Thranduil will be mostly stunned or debuffed.
For gameplay, balance, lore and possible bug-related reasons all the Ring-Heroes (if you prefer main leader of the factions, usually they coincide) cannot be affected by effect 1.
Sauron' servants (Nazgul and Mouth of Sauron) and Sauron himself are immune to all the three effect.
Here you can find the quote from the book about the dragon spell:

Zitat von: Smaug hypnosis
Bilbo was now beginning to feel really uncomfortable. Whenever Smaug's roving eye, seeking for him in the shadows, flashed across him, he trembled, and an unaccountable desire seized hold of him to rush out and reveal himself and tell all the truth to Smaug. In fact he was in grievous danger of coming under the dragon-spell. But plucking up courage he spoke again.


Here's the article (MM Part 2),from moddb, where i get some of the abilities of Smaug.
The article also contains the description of the others most important heroes of MM.

Heroes Of Misty Mountains

THE RING FORM (W.I.P.)


The Golden One: the One ring amplify the greediness of Smaug, making him a more powerful and out of control beast.
Smaug unlocks all his abilities independetly to the tribute system.

Related Ring issue and solution

A problem related to the ring has been found while discussing here in the thread. While flyng, if smaug dies and the ring is dropped, it could be a problem if th One falls in not walkable terrain like rocks or water. In this case Gollum it would remain stuck on that point for all the match, avoiding the players to recover the ring.
For this reason i went to a new solution, presented as follow.
When Smaug pick up the ring, the One is stored in The Dragon Lair (if there are more than one at the same time, the one in which you recruited Smaug).
Beside resolving the aforementioned problem, also it fits even best for Smaug. Many in the forum raised the issue if Smaug can or cannot wear the ring. In my view, would be fitting to consider the ring as the most precious piece of Gold for him. As we all know, once the One recognize his new (temporary) keeper, it starts to cast his influence independently by the wearing or not. I deem this explanation sufficient to justify Smaug "storing" the ring instead of wearing it.
Anyway, coming back to the mechanic it self, the Lair storing the One it will be visible in some way by the other players. If it is destroyed, than Smaug Turns back on his normal form and the ring is available for the other players. If the destroyed Lair was the last in game, also the aforementioned timer start the runnig out.
I don't know about technical problems such as coding. If the storing is not allowed, then the Denethor idea of esperado could be very good imo, also making the ring more visible to the other players.


In flight

"The Golden Armor (passive)": when Smaug wears the Ring, his whole body is immediatly covered by a Golden Armor. His armor is improved to +100% against arrows but his Flying-speed is reduced to -25%.

On the ground

"Immeasurable Greediness" (passive)": through the whispers of the ring, the sickness of Smaug becomes an Immeasurable Greediness. The debuff on buldings (both enemies and allies) is -50%.

Note: the palantir is a tribute to The Professor, from his drawing "Conversation with Smaug".

“My Claws are Spears”: armor against spearmen is increased to +50% but  the trampling damage affects also your own unit.
This should give Smaug more chances to go through the masses without losing health too fast; especially against elitè and heroic pikemen, which usually have a massive revenge damage against monsters.

The Golden armor will be graphically visible during game through a golden tone texture (both in flight and on the ground).
The other powers remain the same but are more effective: the elemental damage (fire, wind) as well as the melee damage are increased. However, the madness of Smaug make him even more careless and cruel: his attack and abilities strike also allies if they are on his path.

IN FAVOUR

1. Aulë
2. Walküre
3. Dain@
4. dkbluewizard
5. Artificialis
6. Astapor
7. Fredius
8. TheDarkOne
9. Julio229
10. Gandalf7000
11. esparado87
12. OakenShield224
13. NoldorSithLordsShipwrigh t
14. FilipGeorg95
15. Spacetyrant93
16. The Witch-King of Angmar
17. Garlodur
18. Tiberius Ogden
19. tolgayurdal


AGAINST
« Letzte Änderung: 1. Mai 2020, 14:30 von AulëTheSmith »

Walküre

  • Edain Unterstützer
  • Hoher König von Gondor
  • ***
  • Beiträge: 4.706
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #1 am: 11. Okt 2017, 15:38 »
I have no other words to add to the ones I have already written. This is a wonderful concept and you, Aulë, have proved yourself a great craftsman of ideas and proposals. Marvellously written and conceived ;)


Thou shalt be given GREEN LIGHT from me.

Halbarad

  • Edain Unterstützer
  • Soldat Gondors
  • ***
  • Beiträge: 1.682
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #2 am: 11. Okt 2017, 19:35 »
1. No fireball and no fireflies - I totaly agree with you in that point
2. “I’m fire, I’m death” - I would like to see him with a skill like that, but only if it's not in slow motion. Maybe he could fly faster and near to the ground while he spits fire, then fly high again. Maybe he could repeat that a few times.

Tribute System
I like your idea of leveling him with money, but by using this system you can get Smaug way too early. Especially factions Imladris would have really big problems against a 500 ress Smaug in the early game. His first appearance should be in the lategame like Drogoth did in Edain 3.8.1. Smaug and other dragons shouldn't be the center of Misty Mountains. It should stay focused on Orcs, Wargs, and trolls. And the most important effect of Misty Mountains central spell should not be related to an outpost building.

Dain@

  • Pförtner von Bree
  • *
  • Beiträge: 95
  • baruk khazad khazad? ai-menu. For the King ! ! !
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #3 am: 11. Okt 2017, 22:58 »
Dear AulëTheSmith . It's just brilliant and insanely good work. Your proposal deserves praise. Great ideas and very beautiful icons for abilities. Truly a worthy offer. As for the abilities of Smaug, I give you my voice +1. But I would like to clarify a few points.
1) What is the essence of the Dragon's disease ability?
2) For the ability "My claws are spears" only suggest adding + 25/30% armor against spearmen. This will give the best effect for a breakthrough through the ranks of enemies.
3) How the ability of the "Hypnotic Gaze" works. I support your vision of the essence of this ability, but how do you propose to implement it? It will be an analog of a powerful fear ability that will also spread to heroes (passive ability as nazgul, only more powerful), or on the contrary it will be an active ability that will weaken an individual hero ???
But I am categorically opposed to the fact that Smaug was central to the book of spells. I believe that the best place for Smaug is the last attacking ability for 10 points. The reason is simple, Despite the fact that even for me Smaug is one of the most beloved heroes, and thanks to you AulëTheSmith and your proposal, so also the most beautiful along with the Necromancer, but nevertheless my answer is simple: the central ability should reflect the essence of the faction, and in this case the specific character of the orcs of the Misty Mountains. I personally lean towards a raid. The essence of it in the following: receiving money, and updating the armor and weapons at the expense of dead enemies. (update armor and weapons only apply to goblins, for trolls and others will have to buy). Also, despite the confluence of circumstances, since the goblins and dragons fought against the dwarves, Smaug was not once in league with the goblins. But if this argument may seem a little I offer a few more nuances for discussion:
1) Smaug too strong for a stationary hero
2) Smaug as a stationary hero leads to an imbalance, the Misty Mountains already have Bolg (a very strong tank / leader), Azog, the Great Goblin, the leader of the goblins of Moria, Tom, Beal and Burt. Well, do not forget about the Super Balrog;
3) What ability can be offered for 10 points ??? if it's not Smaug.
So, if we summarize all of the above, then I propose the following: What would Smaug be a recruiting hero for 10 points. But thanks to your proposal dear AulëTheSmith with the tribute system you can adjust the time of the call of Smaug. I do not know about you, but it seems to me that this will be the best compromise for the Misty Mountains.
I apologize AulëTheSmith for my criticism. But you definitely get my vote +1. Bravo !!! And yes, I almost forgot the ring system just super, which is only gold armor !!! Elegant work AulëTheSmith !!!

Walküre

  • Edain Unterstützer
  • Hoher König von Gondor
  • ***
  • Beiträge: 4.706
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #4 am: 12. Okt 2017, 02:13 »
It is very legitimate to wonder whether Smaug would be a too destructive of a feature in the early game. Moreover, as it's stated above, Smaug is also supposed to be an ultimate feature himself, which you would normally purchase/recruit in the late phase of the game. That is the additional fun and particularity of ultimate heroes of his ilk. So, I guess it would be right to increase the amount of resources needed, in order to make the tribute system function wisely.

On the other hand, Smaug is equally portrayed as a sudden calamity, which has suddenly devastated a mighty realm and taken possession of anything under the erstwhile rule. We can thus consider him being playable earlier as an interesting reference to this aspect. Smaug will nonetheless remain limited until the spell is made active.

dkbluewizard

  • Gastwirt zu Bree
  • **
  • Beiträge: 125
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #5 am: 12. Okt 2017, 06:50 »
I AM IN FAVOR OF THIS AWESOME CONCEPT
Outside of Lord of the Rings, I am pretty sure Vengeance of Valdorian & Leoj's Wrath are the best novels I have read.

AulëTheSmith

  • Elronds Berater
  • **
  • Beiträge: 300
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #6 am: 12. Okt 2017, 13:14 »
I have no other words to add to the ones I have already written. This is a wonderful concept and you, Aulë, have proved yourself a great craftsman of ideas and proposals. Marvellously written and conceived ;)

Thank you very much for your kind words Walküre the wisest and most skilled  :)
Also, thank you for your help in the editing of the post, i probably exaggerated in saving space, using too much the spoiler's button  :D :D Now it is more visible.

I AM IN FAVOR OF THIS AWESOME CONCEPT

I apologize AulëTheSmith for my criticism. But you definitely get my vote +1. Bravo !!! And yes, I almost forgot the ring system just super, which is only gold armor !!! Elegant work AulëTheSmith !!!

I've inserted both of you in the in favour list. Thank you very much for your support guys. Don't be afraid to share your critics, i'm the first one to be happy if we reach an optimal point through this thread. This goal can be reached only passing through critics and discussions :) it is the salt of the forum.
Some claryfications:

Tribute System
I like your idea of leveling him with money, but by using this system you can get Smaug way too early. Especially factions Imladris would have really big problems against a 500 ress Smaug in the early game. His first appearance should be in the lategame like Drogoth did in Edain 3.8.1. Smaug and other dragons shouldn't be the center of Misty Mountains. It should stay focused on Orcs, Wargs, and trolls. And the most important effect of Misty Mountains central spell should not be related to an outpost building.

- About the tribute system you are probably right: as also Walküre wrote, it wisely needs some cost increasing. I shall modify the values. But, consider that you have to spend at least 800 resources to build the outpost, and then other 500 to have Smaug for 2 minutes, so a total of 1300. It is not a negligible amount in early game :)
i think anyway that could be a problem if you are against late game factions: even if you don't destroy your enemy (2 minutes are not sufficient), you could cause severe damages. So a cost of at least 750 it is more balanced for the level 1 tribute.
I don't agree with the central spell issue: Smaug and fire-drakes will be a special feature of MM and MM only. MM will be only possibility to play with dragons in the entire game, and because of removal of Drogoth, Smaug will be the only dragon leader of the entire game. Dragons are a very special characteristic of MM;orcs,trolls and wargs/wolves are instead shared with other evil factions. Because of this uniqueness i think Smaug and/or the other dragon breeds worth to be inserted in the central spellbook, along with the other monsters of MM.
Following the logic of infesting/pillaging which is the central theme of my spell, dragons are the best (and powerful) example of this pludering and stealing nature.
About the outpost issue: MM will have a partial free-building system, so that you will have, at the beginnig, only the Moria's base. All the other sub-faction/monster lairs need an existing outpost or the construction of the new one with the just mentioned free-building mechanic. Therefore, i think outposts need to be involved in my central spell anyway. I don't see any particular problem in this sense :)

Halbarad, can i list you as in favour? Do you prefer to think more about the proposal and see how it will evolve?

Dear AulëTheSmith . It's just brilliant and insanely good work. Your proposal deserves praise. Great ideas and very beautiful icons for abilities. Truly a worthy offer. As for the abilities of Smaug, I give you my voice +1. But I would like to clarify a few points.
1) What is the essence of the Dragon's disease ability?
2) For the ability "My claws are spears" only suggest adding + 25/30% armor against spearmen. This will give the best effect for a breakthrough through the ranks of enemies.
3) How the ability of the "Hypnotic Gaze" works. I support your vision of the essence of this ability, but how do you propose to implement it? It will be an analog of a powerful fear ability that will also spread to heroes (passive ability as nazgul, only more powerful), or on the contrary it will be an active ability that will weaken an individual hero ???
But I am categorically opposed to the fact that Smaug was central to the book of spells. I believe that the best place for Smaug is the last attacking ability for 10 points. The reason is simple, Despite the fact that even for me Smaug is one of the most beloved heroes, and thanks to you AulëTheSmith and your proposal, so also the most beautiful along with the Necromancer, but nevertheless my answer is simple: the central ability should reflect the essence of the faction, and in this case the specific character of the orcs of the Misty Mountains. I personally lean towards a raid. The essence of it in the following: receiving money, and updating the armor and weapons at the expense of dead enemies. (update armor and weapons only apply to goblins, for trolls and others will have to buy). Also, despite the confluence of circumstances, since the goblins and dragons fought against the dwarves, Smaug was not once in league with the goblins. But if this argument may seem a little I offer a few more nuances for discussion:
1) Smaug too strong for a stationary hero
2) Smaug as a stationary hero leads to an imbalance, the Misty Mountains already have Bolg (a very strong tank / leader), Azog, the Great Goblin, the leader of the goblins of Moria, Tom, Beal and Burt. Well, do not forget about the Super Balrog;
3) What ability can be offered for 10 points ??? if it's not Smaug.
So, if we summarize all of the above, then I propose the following: What would Smaug be a recruiting hero for 10 points. But thanks to your proposal dear AulëTheSmith with the tribute system you can adjust the time of the call of Smaug. I do not know about you, but it seems to me that this will be the best compromise for the Misty Mountains.
I apologize AulëTheSmith for my criticism. But you definitely get my vote +1. Bravo !!! And yes, I almost forgot the ring system just super, which is only gold armor !!! Elegant work AulëTheSmith !!!

"My claws are spears" : considering it is a level 7 ability, could be a good idea to increase the armor against revenge damage up to +30-50%. After all, he is a big and very well armored dragon ;)

"Hypnotic Gaze": a temporary conversion of a single enemy hero would be a good idea. My first post in this forum was this kind of proposition but for Sauron. Now that i think about it, Smaug could be a good candidate for this power. I would like to know what was the initial meaning of this power when the team had this idea  [ugly]

"Dragon Sickness": it comprises the very nature of Smaug. He steals resources wherever he goes because is very greedy. Basically he doesn't care about the difference between allies and enemies when it comes to treasures.

I think a 10 points spell would be too much if you must also spend 3000 additional resources to build him. With the current system, that is the path if you want a permanent Smaug:
- purchase of the outpost (around 800 resources or more)
- leveling up of the Dragon Lair, which means you have to recruit drakes, which are very expensive! (at least 1000 each)
- purchase of the central spell of 5 points.
- with a level 3 lair and the central spell unlocked you have to spend, finally, 3000 resources.
- considering you recruited 3 drakes (to level up the Lair) we have 3000 resources, plus the final cost we have a total of 6000, plus the cost of the outpost we are around 6800-7000 resources (+ 5 spellbook's points). it is a very high cost  [ugly]. if you compare him with other mass slayers (Gandalf,Saruman), Smaug's total price is more than double.
- finally, you have to do all of this avoiding your enemy to destroy the Dragon Lair, which is more vulnerable than usual citadels (very well protected).

Also, considering the last news: i would not bind Smaug to a specific side (long term) of the new spellbooks' system. I think there are many other good ideas for a long term 10 pp power in contrast to the quick and powerful Balrog (logically placed in the short-term/offensive side).

 
 



Walküre

  • Edain Unterstützer
  • Hoher König von Gondor
  • ***
  • Beiträge: 4.706
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #7 am: 12. Okt 2017, 15:18 »
Smaug as a central spell would be the only logical solution, if we are to tie him to the spellbook in the first place. Otherwise, there wouldn't be many other options, I guess. The legacy of the Balrog representing one of the ultimate powers should be absolutely maintained, and it will serve the logic of the short-term branch of the very spellbook. Hypothetical Smaug-related spells won't simply stand a chance against the memory of the Balrog; even worse scenario, Smaug would be a terrible long-term spell, by the strictest definition. Thus, the central position of the feature might be the compromise we need find.

The character itself is just too relevant in the new Hobbit-fashioned design of the faction. It is why I don't think that comparing things with how the previous version of the faction used to fare could bring many useful arguments. The pivotal theme of greed and infestation would be kept anyway.

AulëTheSmith

  • Elronds Berater
  • **
  • Beiträge: 300
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #8 am: 12. Okt 2017, 16:36 »
Just an update guys: i've scaled the values of tributes system, now it is more expensive.
I repeat what i wrote in the concept: values can change, both regarding time and resources. This is valid for all the features of the concept.
Consider also that values need to be tested directly in game, something cleary not possible at the moment. I simply put some values i deem more reasonable, but the final proof will be the feedbacks of betatesters  ;)

Artificialis

  • Bilbos Festgast
  • *
  • Beiträge: 10
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #9 am: 13. Okt 2017, 01:53 »
I like the idea of Smaug having both a ground and flying form based on the animations of Summoned Dragon and Drogoth from the original game. I also like the different abilities you have proposed. Although it would probably make the Misty Mountains way too powerful, I would not mind having Smaug as a stationary hero. Especially if he would have all of these abilities. I do not want him to disappear before I used all of his abilities you know. :P But perhaps it is for the best if he becomes one of the two final spellbook powers, the Balrog being the other one.

I would love to see Smaug make an appearance in the game. I would be happy with many incarnations of the character, but your concept for Smaug is definitely something I support. I am also very much in favor of having a golden Smaug as the factions ring-hero. Which could just be a simple reskin of the character model.

''There is one who I could follow.. There is one I could call king..''

dkbluewizard

  • Gastwirt zu Bree
  • **
  • Beiträge: 125
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #10 am: 13. Okt 2017, 06:55 »
I don't know Aule, I don't want Smaug to be too expensive, I mean, he could be devastating to armies, but he could not hold a candle to Sauron, Saruman, Gandalf, Galadriel, Elrond, or the Balrog (not a permanent hero so who cares), and maybe Glorfindel would be too much for him as well.

So the fact is this, I agree with everything, but I can only see a high price for Smaug's devestation on the army units, he should not be able to beat Sauron, Saruman, Gandalf, Galadriel, Elrond, or maybe Glorfindel/Alatar.

So with that in mind, he shouldn't be too expensive unless he is devastating to army units more than the above mentioned.
Outside of Lord of the Rings, I am pretty sure Vengeance of Valdorian & Leoj's Wrath are the best novels I have read.

AulëTheSmith

  • Elronds Berater
  • **
  • Beiträge: 300
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #11 am: 13. Okt 2017, 14:05 »
I like the idea of Smaug having both a ground and flying form based on the animations of Summoned Dragon and Drogoth from the original game. I also like the different abilities you have proposed. Although it would probably make the Misty Mountains way too powerful, I would not mind having Smaug as a stationary hero. Especially if he would have all of these abilities. I do not want him to disappear before I used all of his abilities you know. :P But perhaps it is for the best if he becomes one of the two final spellbook powers, the Balrog being the other one.

I would love to see Smaug make an appearance in the game. I would be happy with many incarnations of the character, but your concept for Smaug is definitely something I support. I am also very much in favor of having a golden Smaug as the factions ring-hero. Which could just be a simple reskin of the character model.

I've listed you as in favour, thank you very much for your support ;) Regarding the 10pp spell for Smaug, as i post above, i think it would be too much, in addition there are many other ideas in the forum about a possible log term spell, for example the summon of Azog's banner from the movie ;)
I will also be more clear about how the power of Smaug should be balanced, as an answer to dkblue:

I don't know Aule, I don't want Smaug to be too expensive, I mean, he could be devastating to armies, but he could not hold a candle to Sauron, Saruman, Gandalf, Galadriel, Elrond, or the Balrog (not a permanent hero so who cares), and maybe Glorfindel would be too much for him as well.
So the fact is this, I agree with everything, but I can only see a high price for Smaug's devestation on the army units, he should not be able to beat Sauron, Saruman, Gandalf, Galadriel, Elrond, or maybe Glorfindel/Alatar.
So with that in mind, he shouldn't be too expensive unless he is devastating to army units more than the above mentioned.

Smaug, in my vision, should be a very well armored and tanky mass slayer, probably the most powerful one.

on the ground: he should naturally suffer more damage from pikes and heroes; especially Bard, Gandalf and other heroes which have some effective skills against monsters.
Specifically about the theme "heroes vs Smaug": considering him on the ground,he  should be slow and his attack frequency low (rembember: apart of the melee values, also the frequency is important, the most illuminating of the example is Sauron(excluding "Dark Will")), such that it will be very difficult for him to win in a single combat against powerful heroes. Take this video as an example, this is the animation of the summoned dragon:


As you can see,  he's very tanky so it is difficult to kill him quickly using standard melee attack, giving you the possibility to flee or to support him with troops. But, at the same time, he's considerably slow and not effective against single target (even worse would be if he's sorrounded by more than one hero). That's exactly the trade-off i would like to see for Smaug in the future. 
The increased cost and longer path to recruit him, are justified by the fact that i would like to see him more armored and tanky, therefore more tough to kill.
Also, he would get some new devasting AOE attack such as "I'm fire,I'm death".
Remeber also that you would get some drawbacks with my concept, for example "dragon sickness" force you to keep Smaug far from the core of your productive/economy system. another example: you have to take care when you use "I'm fire, I'm death", because if you set fire on the ground, also your units will inevitably burn. Furthermore, all the drawbacks are amplified when you pick up the ring. 

As for the in flight version, again his melee attack shouldn't be very effective against heroes, but rather more against troops and, in a medium way, also against buildings.  ;). He should naturally suffer single target powerful attack from heroes, such as the black arrow of Bard, the twin arrows of Legolas, the spear throwed by Eomer/Eowyn ect ect. This would also underline his weakness due to the famous hole in his the armor ;)
 
I hope i make my vision more clear  [ugly] :D



 

Astapor

  • Hobbit
  • *
  • Beiträge: 4
  • Lord Astapor
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #12 am: 13. Okt 2017, 14:32 »
Good job man. I really wish to see this in a game :) Perfect.
The Black Lieutenant, Faithless and Accursed, The Messenger, The Mouth, Voice of the Abhorred Dead Titles Lieutenant of Barad-dûr, Messenger of Mordor, Emissary of the Dark Lord, Ambassador of Sauron, Captain of the Black Uruks, the "Mannish Lieutenant" of all Orcs of Mordor

AulëTheSmith

  • Elronds Berater
  • **
  • Beiträge: 300
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #13 am: 13. Okt 2017, 19:33 »
Good job man. I really wish to see this in a game :) Perfect.

Thank you Astapor, I'm glad you like the concept ;) I shall list you as in favor   ;)

Fredius

  • Edain Betatesting
  • Galadhrim
  • ***
  • Beiträge: 712
  • It's good to be evil
Re: Smaug, the Cheapest and Greatest of Calamities
« Antwort #14 am: 13. Okt 2017, 19:50 »
Like I said in the other thread, I agree :).