Modding Union

[en] Edain Mod => [Edain] Edain Multiplayer => [Edain] Strategy => Thema gestartet von: Lord of Mordor am 26. Jul 2015, 01:00

Titel: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Lord of Mordor am 26. Jul 2015, 01:00
Just had a particular epic match? Or maybe you stumbled upon a balancing problem that's best illustrated by watching it in action? This is where you can share your replays with the community and the team! You can attach the replay file directly to your post so you don't have to upload it anywhere else. We're always curious to see how people play our mod to gain a better understanding of our fans :)


Edit:
Only upload files if every player(who played in this game) agreed. If one or more player doesn't want his replay uploaded, then please accept his decision and don't upload the game.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 30. Jul 2015, 19:47
3x3 game with : 3 Rohan vs 2 Isengard + 1 Dwarves
Disclaimer: it was a game I played before I went on vacation, i.e. WITHOUT 4.1.1. It may not work properly.

Outcome of the game (don't click if you don't want to get spoiled)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 4. Aug 2015, 18:03
- Game1 : 2v2 Buckland
Mordor (kahmhalt) and Gondor (|SlSev| Ele) VS. Iron Hills (Woppader) and Isengard (me)

- Game2 : FFA Belfalas
Rohan (me) VS. Gondor (Eribour) VS. Isengard (Woppader) VS. Gondor (Skeeverboy) VS. Gondor (kahmhalt)

Both games on the current 4.1.1 patch.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 6. Aug 2015, 22:55
Battle between Mordor (me) and Rohan (Szurdok) Vs Ered Luin(Kryptik) and Mordor(Sawman).
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 9. Aug 2015, 17:15
FFA on Himling map.

Rohan(me) vs Mordor(I see you) vs Isengard(H4lbarad)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 10. Aug 2015, 17:24
4v4 on Adorn River
Mordor (Woppader) and Isengard (Mogat) and Gondor (Caun) and Gondor (Photti)
VS. Isengard (Eorl175) and Rohan (3_finger) and Gondor (XB Jimpack) and Mordor (me)

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 13. Aug 2015, 18:31
FFA on Harlindon.
Erebor(I see you) Ered Luin(DarkRadek) and Isengard(me)
This match demonstrates just how insanely strong the Ered Luin heroes are late game, and how insanely strong an Isengard army is once its upgraded. It also demonstrates my point that no army can kill Isengard once they have their army upgraded and heroes leveled up. Grima's ability to make enemy heroes do 0 damage is especially useful against Dwarves.

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 16. Aug 2015, 01:46
This was an extremely fun 2v2 on Buckland, me and 3 of my friends are all nearly equal skill level, which resulted in excellent tug of wars all game long. It is a long replay though, so grab some popcorn! :D

Players are Gondor(me), Mordor(Sawman), Rohan(DarkRadek), and Isengard(Draco10000).

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 16. Aug 2015, 01:56
Here a 1v1 on Fords of Isen 2.

Players:
Gondor (Skeeverboy)
Mordor (Hypnotix)

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 18. Aug 2015, 21:49
4v4 on Adorn River, with lots of great teamwork on both sides.
Rohan(me) Mordor(King Dain) Isengard(Sawman) and Isengard(DarkRadek)
VS
Ered Luin(VAINORD)  Isengard(Isil) Mordor(NightMerry) and Erebor(Limbo)

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 20. Aug 2015, 18:08
1v1 on Gap of Rohan
Mordor(me) vs Gondor(DarkRadek)
This match demonstrates how OP Mordor is. Even with the glitch that happened, preventing Sauron from leveling up, I was still able to completely shut down and defeat him with level 1 Sauron. This is due primarily to the new change of economy structures, which makes Gondor and Isengard extremely weak early game. After I got total map control there wasn't anything he could do to break me, and if I had a level 10 Sauron it would've been even more hopeless. This match also shows one of the most annoying exploits for Mordor, which is Shelob's webbing freezing 4 or 5 battalions of troops at once.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 21. Aug 2015, 11:40
3v3 on Mirkwood
Isengard Rohan Gondor VS. Rohan Mordor Gondor
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 23. Aug 2015, 17:51
3v3 on Dagorlad
Gondor Mordor Isengard VS. Gondor Mordor Isengard

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 24. Aug 2015, 15:54
FFA on Mirkwood
Dwarves VS. Mordor VS. Gondor VS. Dwarves

One of the best game I've ever played, about 1h30 minutes long. A status quo happened quite fast between Mordor, Gondor and Dwarves which lead to epic battles. Every power was used and every hero was on the battlefield. There is even a ring hero in the end.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: CragLord am 26. Aug 2015, 23:37
My comment contains SPOILER in term of winner of this match. :)  :P
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 27. Aug 2015, 10:55

My answer:
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 27. Aug 2015, 12:30
Well, looks like there wasn't any issue at all.  :)

Just played two very different 1v1s.

Game 1 : 1v1 on Brandywine
Rohan VS. Isengard

Game 2 : 1v1 on Fords of Isen 2
Gondor VS. Rohan

If you are looking for a short and very agressive game, watch the first one.
If you are looking for a siege, watch the second one.

NB: My opponent had to leave the second game as it lasted longer than expected.


EDIT: Last game for the day: 3v3 on Nurn
Mordor and Rohan and Gondor VS. Gondor and Mordor and Mordor
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 29. Aug 2015, 00:44
Here a very good 1v1 from Prinz (Gondor) and Andy (Isengard). Here you can see, that Isengard can be very strong in the EG.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 29. Aug 2015, 22:29
Here a 1v1 from Woppader (Gondor) and Prinz (Isengard).
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: CragLord am 30. Aug 2015, 02:58
I know this is maybe unnecessarily for now (because there is not so much shared replays), but maybe (from future perspective) would be nice to include version of Edain mod in which replay is saved in replay's name (or to indicate that mod version in comment on which replay is attached)?  :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Gnomi am 3. Sep 2015, 16:36
I've just edited the first comment, to fit with the german part:

Don't upload a replay if one or more of the players(who played in this game) don't want it.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: (Palland)Raschi am 3. Sep 2015, 19:06
Zitat
Don't upload a replay if one or more of the players(who played in this game) don't want it.

Otherwise it could be embarrassing for some players :D
(I do not see any other reason why this would be a problem, but Mods word is law ^^)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 5. Sep 2015, 13:00
Three 1v1s on Fords of Isen 2.

Game 1: Dwarves (Ered Luin) VS. Gondor
Game 2: Rohan VS. Rohan
Game 3: Isengard VS. Dwarves (Erebor)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: CragLord am 25. Sep 2015, 21:20
Really liked that third game. Nice Bilbo micro. :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 17. Okt 2015, 23:40
Here a very very very fast 1v1 from Skeeverboy (Rohan) and Beautiful Darkness (Gondor).


Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 25. Okt 2015, 00:20
Here a funny 4v4 with very very very much dunlands [uglybunti].
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 11. Nov 2015, 08:33
Hi! Back with the first two 4.2 replays! :D

Both games are 4v4 in Tournament Hills. You can expect every faction in both games.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 15. Nov 2015, 10:03
Hi guys.  :) Game1 Erebor and Gondor VS. Gondor and Lothlorien
Game2 Iron Hills and Erebor VS. two Lothlorien

The first game is a full game with no afk/gamecrash/bug.
The second game ended up early because of synch. bug but is very interesting I think.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 17. Nov 2015, 23:00
2v2 on Buckland Mordor and Elves VS. Rohan and Gondor
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: pauldums am 18. Nov 2015, 22:52
Hi ! It is a funny 2vs2 (Erebor Gondor vs Mordor Lothlorien) where Dwarves show nice abilities in defence.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 20. Nov 2015, 23:37
Game1: Isengard and Isengard VS. Rohan and Gondor on Osgiliath (nice map btw)


EDIT: A lot of replays in this post and in the following. (restriction of 3 per post..  8-| )
Descriptions in the names.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 22. Nov 2015, 18:51
And the remaining ones.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 22. Nov 2015, 20:31
Loving the replays man! Keep them coming as they seriously aid in improving my game.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 23. Nov 2015, 16:55
Thank you, I really appreciate that. :)
My very first goal with those replays was to incite other people to post replays aswell, as I myself enjoy watching good games of Edain. :) Even though it didn't really work, I kept uploading them because they always got a few downloads. However, I was thinking to stop for some people asked me to take off some replays just because they lost and I found it quite sad. So thanks for that comment, I'll keep uploading the interesting games I play. :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 23. Nov 2015, 17:41
Don't let it get to you. The uploads help a big deal!

On a unrelated note, I am actually looking for a tutor to help me improve my Edain game. I was hoping if you would be willing to, or if you know someone else who would be willing to do so xD? Mostly looking for 1v1s, but 2v2s will do as well.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: ringbearer am 23. Nov 2015, 17:50
You are lucky guys that you can play online  :) I am left with AI :D ... Yeah , don't stop Adrigabbro. If i have a time to spare I really like watching your games :) If you could do 1vs1 more that would be even better :D
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 23. Nov 2015, 21:43
Are you playing on tunngle or gameranger? (I got both) I'd gladly play with you. :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 23. Nov 2015, 23:24
Check your PM!
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 25. Nov 2015, 01:38
1v1 on Gulf of Lune. Good match, but the reason I'm posting is to demonstrate how impossible it is to win as Lothlorien if your enemy uses only cavalry. My army consists almost entirely of pikes at one point, and he rides right over them. I even use the Minstrels ability to make units immune to trample, and it still isn't enough to stop him. The best counter they previously had was Beornings, but now since they can be trampled in human form and do little damage in bear form, they cannot effectively counter cavalry. This is troublesome, because they were OP before. I think immunity to trample should be restore to their human form. The match is quite long because my enemy can't finish me off, only the first half hour is really relevant to my point.

Another point as well is that because the command points upgrade is on the Border Guardhouse only, it forces the player to have at least 2 of these, making it impossible to get discounts on galadhrim or upgrades without sacrificing a building type. I think that instead of having command points on the guardhouse, it should be moved to the citadel if its possible. This would allow players to customize their playstyle however they see fit.

I just remembered a third point that needs mentioning. Catapults are WAY too strong. I summoned eagles and they couldn't even kill a single catapult, same goes for radagast and tauriel, and silverthorn arrows. The current health of the catapult allows players to send in poorly guarded attacks with lots of catapults, without actually using strategy. They need a health nerf, or units need to deal more damage to them, ESPECIALLY eagles.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: CragLord am 25. Nov 2015, 02:42
I would also love to discuss about those things on balance topic, I also think beornings should have that trample immunity.
Concerning Eagle's problem, Elite check this topic, and leave there your contribution about this Flying Units problem here (if you already haven't): Link (http://en.modding-union.com/index.php/topic,31584.0.html)
Poll is pretty "old", and from time of its creation until now, situation is same, so I think every vote is needed there. ;)

Regards,
CragLord
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 26. Nov 2015, 07:42
Heres a funny game between me and a friend. He is new to the multiplayer, so don't be ragging about his gameplay :P

So we were playing on Dunland, and I happened to get Isengard. Therefore I decided it would be brilliant if I made nothing but Wildmen and spammed him like crazy, and I ended up winning the match xD

I wasn't playing seriously, although I can't speak for him, but this was just a fun match, not a competitive one, for me at least. Should be enjoyable to watch ;)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: ™Æ¿® Aragorn £ ‡™ am 26. Nov 2015, 12:11
Here's an interesting replay, it's an ffa with Rohan, Ered luin, Gondor, and lothlorien.               In this replay, you really get to see what Dwarven defenders are against elven archers  :D     
and of course how ered luin is with Balin's runes being unlocked by leveling up.
                                                                                                                                            - I checked with the players in this match.                                                                                      and please excuse the name of it :P.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 29. Nov 2015, 04:05
This was a fun game on the new flavor cair Andros, which really needs balancing btw, but anyways its a normal game up until the very end, when something...... interesting happens. Enjoy :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 29. Nov 2015, 22:40
Replays of the week ! (lol) Ye, they now come in waves.  :)
I think they are all interesting in some ways.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 29. Nov 2015, 22:41
Second post.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 29. Nov 2015, 22:43
Third and final post. Hope you enjoy them. :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 29. Nov 2015, 22:47
*Grabs popcorn and soda*
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 2. Dez 2015, 05:14
Here is a long, epic 2v2 featuring Lothlorien(me), Gondor(Adis) against Rohan(Sawman) and Gondor(Haman). There are lots of great huge battles in this match, and some excellent play by Haman, and I do a decent job as well, holding off several double attacks on my own. Should be an enjoyable watch. Just a note, Adis is relatively new to the game, and his play isn't great with any factions but evil ones, which are his favorite. So don't be too hard on him. Enjoy!
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Melkor Bauglir am 2. Dez 2015, 19:54
6 Replays downloaded = Evening's leisure activities planned out! :D
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: ™Æ¿® Aragorn £ ‡™ am 8. Dez 2015, 09:34
I just noticed that none of these replays show the iron hills :P.                                                Here, have this one.

Just note that it wasn't a very serious game, and it was 4k.                                                                             

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: -DJANGO- am 8. Dez 2015, 19:55
Here a 1VS1 on FdI II.  Mordor (Goodfella) VS Lorien (me).

Dynamic and intense game, with a lot of movement through the hole Map. I use an unusual Strategy  :D Game was still open when, i got a Tunngle Crash. Would have been a really nice LG...
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 8. Dez 2015, 20:43
Some "old" replays I forgot to upload.  :) (4.2.1 don't worry)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: ringbearer am 11. Dez 2015, 21:52
-DJANGO- .. one of the best replays i've ever seen :) too bad it crashed. ( for the last 5 minutes i was thinking, when the hell is he gonna pop out galadhrim :D ) 
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 15. Dez 2015, 22:16
Here a funny ffa on River Ardon(?).
At the end it was crashed, but it was very funny. (4.2.1)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 23. Dez 2015, 11:35
Some replays!
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 23. Dez 2015, 11:36
Replays² :D
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: CragLord am 23. Dez 2015, 16:30
Adrigabbro, you deserve title "Master of Replays"!  :D
Thanks for sharing, I watch and enjoy in your replays almost always when I get time. :)

Best regards,
CragLord
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 23. Dez 2015, 18:13
Pretty much what Crag said. Once 4.3 hits, and I will finally have time, I will produce replays as well. Looking forward to getting my butt handed to me.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 23. Dez 2015, 18:22
Thx guys. :)

@Odysseus: I haven't seen you on gameranger yet. I still want to play some games with you. :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 28. Dez 2015, 23:29
The first game is a 4000 gold start game. It wasn't my call: as you may see there is no early game with such a start.
There are ring heroes in the second and the third game.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: -DJANGO- am 3. Jan 2016, 15:32
Replays under the Theme "SPAM"  xD
Have fun!
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 3. Jan 2016, 20:09
@Django: I really liked the first game but I think both Gondor players should have tried to get heroes at some point. Anyway rushing winged fellbeasts was a very good strategy.

Here are some replays of mine:
The first game is, in my opinion, a very good 1v1 against a great player: LorienVSMordor.
The second game is a bit chaotic but features nice fights and Sauron with the ring.
The third game is two simultaneous and continuous battles (1v1 top and 2v2 bot) with Gandalf with the ring.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 5. Jan 2016, 00:03
Here a funny 2v2:
Mordor and Lorien vs Isengard and Gondor

Here can you see how powerfull Trolls can be against normal units.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 5. Jan 2016, 18:05
Huh, somebody using Trolls? Lets give this a little watch then :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 5. Jan 2016, 23:06
Great game! Loved the Mordor play ;). Unconventional and satisfying to see.

However, I think there were some very apparent issues. Especially with a/the Isengard-Lothlorien match-up.
This is not a rant, just some concerns of mine:

First and foremost, Isengard took down the Mirkwood Fortress like 3 times at the least, and yet Lothlorien's economy seems to not care? Last I checked, Lothlorien is not a resource-manipulative faction. Surely after taking down Mirkwood 3 times, Lothlorien's economy would actually hurt. I am aware that there was little economy harassment, but still. 5500~ down the drain I roughly estimated in total and Lorien's economy seemed unharmed.

Secondly, I can't wait for the next wave of balance changes to Lothlorien. Usually I don't like employing such words and I apologise in advance for it, but man, Beorningers are so annoying. One-shotting every infantry model, no matter how much they cost or what upgrades they have, doing bizarre damage against heroes for a 450 unit that you can get right of the start and high attack speed combine that into a bag full of shenanigans. It's the only unit that I do not like in this beautiful mod.
 I am confident that ET knows that Beorninger spam is still much too effective, especially in teamgames. Maybe if Beorningers were tweaked or nerfed further, players would actually use Galadhrim. They should be your heavy hitters, in my opinion.

Thirdly, I was glad to see Grimbeorn for once, but he seemed more like a Hero-Killer than a Mass Slayer in this game. He killed Lurtz twice, and Ugluk once I think. Him walking around a couple of Beorningers is just something to run away from at the sight. That's with most of the units and heroes in Lothlorien. The majority of them seem to do so well against heroes. Ents do crazy, crazy damage against heroes, easily 2/3 hitting Lurtz, Beorningers do high damage against heroes, Grimbeorn does high damage to heroes for a mass slayer, Haldir performs quite nicely for his cost against most heroes of similar cost.

I hope that the next patch or the patch after that will finally put Lothlorien in its place and make it less frustrating to face.

Apart from not mentioning the Gondor player, which I was not sure what he was doing, only getting regular troops, the Isengard should have focussed less on pikes and gotten out more uruk crossbowmen to counter those ents and the regular troops as well, since he was actually doing well with his economy, which generally speaking is where Isengard kind of struggles in 1v1 and in small 2v2 maps like this.

The Isengard-Lothlorien MU is really awkward in my opinion, because of Beorningers and Ents.

Anyway, enough of that. I look forward to see what ET can concoct :P.

Odysseus out.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 6. Jan 2016, 08:34
That was a fun watch, but my god that Gondor player was terrible. All he needed was tower guards and a couple archers and your whole strategy was kaput.

This replay serves as prime evidence of 2 serious problems edain currently has: The Trolls uselessness and the Beornings overpowered-ness. You spent god knows how much replacing those trolls as they were cut down by basic Gondor pikes. If you had spent that on Cirith Ungol orcs and Heroes this match would've been over quickly.

On the other hand, the Beornings just wouldn't die. At one point, I saw Lurtz kill freaking CELEBORN, aka the hero killer of Lorien, and then get wrecked by 3 beornings :D Just for comparison, Celeborn is over 2k, 3 Beornings are just over 1k. That was a good laugh. Something definitely should be done about both of these units, but great replay nonetheless :)

As for the Ents, that's a tough call to make. They were far too weak last patch, but I am leaning towards thinking they are a bit too strong in this one, at least against heroes. I think they should be nerfed a bit against heroes, dealing less damage to heroes and taking more from them. But that's a discussion that belongs in the Lorien Balance Discussion thread, so I'll say no more.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 6. Jan 2016, 14:04
I just wanted to say that we actually agree on something Elite :D.

I think the problem with Trolls is that they take a ton of trampling damage AND they do not slow down like cavalry. In other words, a troll can keep getting trample crush revenged damaged, so to speak, until it dies.

Although, he did get a couple of Slaughterhouses to make the trolls much cheaper, so eventually the trolls did not cost that much, and they are really good with upgrades, if you ask me.

The Drummer Troll is a beast, his attack has so much knockback and a large AEO, it's crazy. He sends even cavalry flying all over the place. He also has a lot more health than a regular troll it seems. I wonder if that is intentional.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 6. Jan 2016, 14:25
Even with the full discount its over 400 just to get the troll, plus upgrades to make em useful. Far too expensive. I honestly don't know about drummer trolls, I never use them because its not worth it to get the troll cage.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 7. Jan 2016, 00:13
Here a funny 4v4, with strong battle wagons (but sometimes bad micro from me [ugly])
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 7. Jan 2016, 01:43
Heres a game I had with my friend, its not serious just for fun. Epic battle 1v1 on Evendim Island, Rohan vs Ered Luin. Some pretty epic fights and charges in this one. 1 thing to note, we had heavy lag to deal with, which you won't see in the replay, so there may be some glaring mistakes from both of us that neither could remedy due to lag.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 8. Jan 2016, 03:16
These replays are in connection with the posts in the Mordor Balance Discussion thread. Both matches are Rohan(me) vs Mordor(Sawman) with a 1k start. First match on Forlindon, 2nd match on Fords of Isen 2.

Match 1: This match was meant to disprove that a really heavy orc spam is unbeatable. To this end, my opponent got an outpost with 3 orc pits asap to try and overrun me. I gave myself a huge disadvantage in this match, due to the map being Forlindon, which heavily favors Mordor in this matchup. Finally, I set out to do what people have said is impossible, and outspam Mordor. I succeeded, despite a really REALLY bad start to the match for me, and some really poor play from me at the beginning.

Match 2: This was meant to represent a standard game, a 1v1 between Mordor and Rohan, with the only difference being that we knew eachothers races when we began instead of playing random. Theres a great surprise for me at the end in the final attack. Both excellent games, and both proof that Mordor Orcs can be easily, dare I say it, countered and beaten.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 8. Jan 2016, 03:30
You forget to attach the replays, mate :P.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 8. Jan 2016, 04:09
My bad, fixed
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 9. Jan 2016, 03:00
Got a fantastic game here, 2v2 with me(Isengard) Sawman(Gondor) Haman(Rohan) and hard(Dwarves, Iron Hills)
This went back and forth so much, it was a truly awesome game. Its a long one though, so grab some popcorn.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 10. Jan 2016, 02:02
Another great 2v2. Isengard(me) Dwarves/Iron Hills(DarkRadek) Rohan(Draco100000) and Rohan(Haman). This is a long game, but it shows how difficult it can be for Rohan to win if they don't finish the job early on.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 10. Jan 2016, 02:22
Another great 2v2. Isengard(me) Dwarves/Iron Hills(DarkRadek) Rohan(Draco100000) and Rohan(Haman). This is a long game, but it shows how difficult it can be for Rohan to win if they don't finish the job early on.
At the final of this match i got the rohirrim tents, and i couldnt get the armor upgrade and the shield upgrade. The improved tent should give it to them but they dont get it so they still having really low health and become useless in late game. So pls fix this and maybe lategame with rohan wouldnt be so damn hard.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 10. Jan 2016, 18:23
This belongs in Rohan Bug Reports Draco :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 10. Jan 2016, 23:49
My goodness what a game! Yes, there were a couple of mistakes, but they were very few and for the sake of not frustrating Kryptik, I'll refrain from stating them :P. The level of play is high, so new players could definetely learn a couple of things or tricks from this replay.

There were some epic ''WTF'' moments as well for me, like:

And some others, but mostly these I found quite entertaining.

I can only say this: http://i.imgur.com/KYrrHop.png

Cheers!
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 11. Jan 2016, 03:05
I'm glad you enjoyed it, I'll keep posting any epic games I get. Also, the Rohan domination of EG happens very often in my games. Finally, let me know in a PM what mistakes you noticed, I'm quite curious :P
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Hamanathnath am 11. Jan 2016, 14:06

These things to what made the game super enjoyable for me. :) I'm really glad you liked it.  Credit to my teammate, Draco100000, for the amazing teamplay.  1. And 2. Were the most fun things to do in the game for me.
Overall, a great game, would ove to do more.  I'm also glad I'm getting better at playing Rohan. 
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 11. Jan 2016, 15:20
@Haman, my pleasure mate, my pleasure.

To Kryptik: I would send this to you via PM, but I thought I'd place it here, because I thought it wass the only mistake really worth mentioning.

Looking forward to see more of them gents, they always help in improving my game and the game of others, if they watch it, that is.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Mor ho! am 12. Jan 2016, 12:35
Hello, in this replay you can see battle between me(Mor ho!) Isengard versus Sawman- Mordor. Mordor took 2 outposts, isengard built Steelwork. In late game mordor killed Gollum and got the ring. How will it end?
Enjoy your watching!!!
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: DarkRadek am 12. Jan 2016, 14:07
Hey.
Here you can see some ffa with 5 players in late game there is nice fight Lorien vs Mordor so check it and see who win  ;)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Mor ho! am 18. Jan 2016, 14:40
Hello guys! We had very funny ffa. Full of interesting battles. Players: Me(Dvarwes), DarkRadek(Isengard), AnDyBranDy(Mordor), nameless(Isengard), Glemli(Mordor), Leander( Gondor) . In the end stayed dvarwes, mordor and isen. Guess who won :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 21. Jan 2016, 23:52
Here is an epic 3v3 game, between myself(Gondor), DarkRadek(Isengard), Bauglir(Isengard) vs Haman(Gondor), Roknar(Isengard) and Halba(Mordor).

There was so much action in this game frankly I can't cover it all, but I can say that Bauglir was a noob, and fed Radek all his money, while I took on 2 players by myself. There is everything in this game, army of the dead, word of power, fires of isengard, all the other late game spells, Ring Heroes the whole 9 yards. It is also a very long replay, so grab some popcorn :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 24. Jan 2016, 05:31
Got a decent 2v2 here. Unfortunately, the people we were up against were not as good as me and my teammate, but this game does demonstrate how strong Isengards early game is because of wildmen spam. Enjoy :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Sawman am 24. Jan 2016, 21:04
Fun 1v1 mordor vs gondor, the ring was used a few times great battle though enjoy
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Sefie1999AD am 25. Jan 2016, 12:47
Does anyone have a replay with an Iron Hills player? Whenever someone plays as the Dwarves in the replays I've watched here, they seem to choose Ered Luin or Erebor as their subfaction.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Skeeverboy am 25. Jan 2016, 21:37
Here a long (55 minutes) and funny 4v4 on River Ardon.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: DrHouse93 am 5. Feb 2016, 17:47
Hi all^^
This is the first replay I share, and I also must admit that I've been crushed by a friend T_T
In fact, I'd like a suggestion: I was Isengard, he was Mordor, on Eastfold. Could you watch the replay and see what did I got wrong? I think I guessed some things I did wrong, but I'd like to have other opinions, too^^

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Walküre am 5. Feb 2016, 18:48
Chiuso all'angoletto, rimonta?
Questo sì che è un titolo interessante  :D

Translation: In the corner, he catches up?
This is a really interesting title  :D
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: DrHouse93 am 5. Feb 2016, 22:27
For DrHouse93, only  xD

Chiuso all'angoletto, rimonta?
Questo sì che è un titolo interessante  :D

Beh, fondamentalmente è quello che è successo xD
Ha fatto non so che magia e mi ha arato come un campo di grano T_T

Translation: Well, it's basically what happened to me  xD
It did some kind of Magic and it plowed me like a wheat field  8-|
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 7. Feb 2016, 10:04
Two cool replays on Buckland.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 22. Feb 2016, 19:26
I've got a great replay here. A lot of people struggle against Mordor as Gondor in 1v1 matches, and say that Mordor is OP. My friend also had this problem, and asked me to show him how to play against Mordor as Gondor. So here is the replay, where I take him apart and win the game. Its really long though because of how strong Mordors defenses are, which prevent me from defeating him for a long time even after I take map control. Enjoy, hope it helps anybody who's having trouble with 1v1 against Mordor :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 23. Feb 2016, 01:02
One hell of a game! I managed to watch it to the very end! :D
You played it REALLY well, I think you won the game by harassing relentlessly his settlements (and his base) when his army was sitting next to his outpost.

Still, I think you deserved to end it faster. It seems there are a couple things that are overpowered in Mordor- in addition to all the stuff we keep repeating ^^-. First, the little towers should switch back to regular arrows when the big tower with the Influence of Sauron gets destroyed. Secondly, as you pointed out once, one should be able to focus and attack Anatar. That's all that comes to my mind. Great game. :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: ringbearer am 23. Feb 2016, 20:23
Top game Elite :). It would be nice to have an Arnor replay for once. I still think it's a little unbalanced.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 24. Feb 2016, 03:33
Got another good one for you here guys, for any of you who struggle to defeat Lorien with Dwarves, look no further.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 24. Feb 2016, 12:42
Interesting. I noticed you always go pantry update + improved production increase on your economic buildings. Why do you think it is optimum?
Personally, I go full production increase on my settlements and on half my camp's, and I keep the other half for pantry. I pretty much always do that because settlements buildings are far more vulnerable and you wouldn't want to lose your buildings with pantry or improved pantry.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 24. Feb 2016, 15:53
The economic upgrade paths are subject to a lot of debate and personal preference. I consider my path to be the most efficient, getting pantry 1 production 2 everywhere means that you have a good amount of command points and make a good amount of money. You also save a lot of money, although it does slow you down early game. The reason for this is going production 1 pantry 2 costs 750, and going pantry 1 production 2 only costs 600. You don't need 1800 command points early on in the game, but if you do this upgrade method everywhere you will get 1800 once you have map control.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: DrHouse93 am 26. Feb 2016, 17:30
Awesome match on Pelargir between me (Isengard) and a friend (Gondor), a true war of position^^
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 29. Feb 2016, 03:39
So people have asked me to post any good replays I can get where Rohan wins, and I have one here, Rohan vs Isengard. I make a nasty mistake and lose Gamling early on, but bring it back later. Enjoy :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: ringbearer am 1. Mär 2016, 10:45
I really like watching Rohan, they are so well made. Keep replays flowing Elite :) :D
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: radagasti01 am 5. Mär 2016, 03:12
Awesome match on Pelargir between me (Isengard) and a friend (Gondor), a true war of position^^

I opened you like a mussels
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: DrHouse93 am 5. Mär 2016, 03:16
I opened you like a mussels

Nice spoiler^^
And btw, I let you win u.u
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 12. Mär 2016, 15:04
Before I forget, here is a nice replay featuring Rohan cavalry (ironic enough to say, but most Rohan plyers don't actually use cavalry).

EDIT: Another replay: Erebor VS. Gondor on the new map Forelands of Emyn Muil (be sure to stay until the very end. ^^)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 16. Mär 2016, 02:41
Got a great 2v2 here for you guys, gondor/mordor vs double lorien. This game really shows the power of Gondor Knights against Lorien, which is the best strategy for holding them off early game IMO. Enjoy!
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 20. Mär 2016, 03:21
Hey, just in case there's somebody here who hasn't seen in any of the the other 3 places I posted this, I have a Youtube channel now. I won't be posting replays anymore, I'll be posting games directly to my youtube channel, daily if I can manage it. Here is my channel link.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCSUmT7v4uM-UdX28d7F8Dhg
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 1. Apr 2016, 06:18
Well, OK, maybe the occasional replay here as well :D

This is a really awesome game, me and 2 of my friends vs 4 brutal AI on Nanduhirion. We survive the spam and proceed to have some of the most epic moments happen I have ever had happen in an Edain game before: multiple Glorious Charges, Gandalf the Challenge Master Word of Powers, Fires of Isengard and Isengard Unleashed, this game has everything. Its a bit long but man its worth the watch, I assure you :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Sefie1999AD am 2. Apr 2016, 13:54
I've been watching Elite KryPtik and RuudDevil's Edain 4.3 beta videos a lot in the past few days. YouTube videos have the advantage over replays that you can always rewind and fast forward to different parts of the match. I decided to give the above 3-on-4 Brutal match a chance, though. xD

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 2. Apr 2016, 15:43
Siege is overrated against AI, its always better to focus on heroes to get their abilities. That's what wins you the game against AI, is heroes and spellbook powers. You'll also notice how fast Haman got Fire Arrows to deal with those accursed ents, because we knew they were coming. Even if there had been an isengard we would have won, because the dwarf spam was still quite prevalent in that game, and Isengard spams about the same on camp maps. They are only really dangerous on castle maps, where they swap you with siege :P
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Sefie1999AD am 3. Apr 2016, 00:03
You'll also notice how fast Haman got Fire Arrows to deal with those accursed ents, because we knew they were coming.

I checked the replay one more time, this time I focused on observing Haman's actions. I didn't view it all the way again, but I just had to keep watching until Bright Words of Power was used.  xD Too bad I won't be able watch 4.2.1 replays after installing 4.3.

While heroes and upgraded units can take down enemy outposts and bases, don't you think siege is a reasonable strategy against Dol Guldur and Lothlorien fortresses? The former poisons any close-range units and the latter is full of arrow defenders, so you'd take heavy losses without siege.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 3. Apr 2016, 01:15
Yeah but making siege requires another build plot which we can use for resources. You'll notice I didn't even have an armor until quite late in the game, I was more focused on getting troops out since the AI rarely upgrades their troops.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 8. Apr 2016, 21:07
1 battle in Pelargir Erebor(Eriazor)and Ironhills(me) vs Mordor(Andres) and Mordor(Geralt)

Really awesome battle where we can see how overpowered is the non-stop spam of mordor and how can be really good tactic vs dwarves and how can also be a really bad way of playing. I think if my allie would maintain a line in his base he could resist bettrer and without that amount of looses that he had because fighhting in the enemie outpost.

We banned mumaks ( invencibility bug) and ram riders ( extreamly overpowered).

I hope you enjoy it.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 10. Apr 2016, 23:38
Another match with Ironhills this time 1v1 vs elves.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 11. Apr 2016, 23:26
Here a 2v2 Ered Luin (me) and Lothlorien (Legs) vs Gondor(Ryuka) and Lothlorien(GoodFella)

Well this game i show some of super Ered Luin harassment. really effective in early stages but beorniger made me run until I got upgrades xD. Really fun game( at least for me).

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Odysseus am 12. Apr 2016, 01:59
Hey Draco, is this 4.3.1? Just to make sure.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 12. Apr 2016, 12:47
Hey Draco, is this 4.3.1? Just to make sure.

No 4.3
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Adrigabbro am 14. Apr 2016, 20:25
Check out this amazing 3v3 on Nurn. the game is 1 hour and 1 minute long, but it is definitely actionpacked! :)
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Draco100000 am 21. Apr 2016, 14:44
Amazing 1v1 in Fords of Isen between the Elves and the Dwarves Of Ironhills.
version 4.3.1
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Andy am 22. Apr 2016, 10:59
Nice game (allways battle) enjoy :)
Angmar,Rohan vs Mordor,Mordor
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 1. Jun 2016, 10:43
Got a couple of EPIC 1v1 games for you, played by myself vs Goodfella. First is Dwarves(me) vs Rohan(him) on Brandywine, 2nd is Rohan(me) vs Gondor(him) on Fords of Isen 2. The dwarf one is very long, and the fords of isen match is relentlessly action packed.
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: DrHouse93 am 12. Jun 2016, 21:10
An epic long (1:58 hours :D) deathmatch between Gondor, Dwarves of Erebor and Angmar on the River Greyflood^^
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: DrHouse93 am 21. Jun 2016, 21:41
The forces of Mordor have attacked the Eastfold. Will the Rohirrim be able to drive them back, or they will die against the might of Sauron?
Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Elite KryPtik am 16. Nov 2016, 20:41
Well, nothing has been posted here in a while! Here is a great replay featuring myself and drhouse in a 1v1

Titel: Re: Share Your Replays!
Beitrag von: Goodfella am 5. Apr 2017, 22:41
Hi, I've got quite an epic 1v1 for you between me and dmitry on fords of isen 2. Dmitry plays Mordor and goes for trolls whilst i play gondor and go for early cavalry.

I've also uploaded this replay to my brand-new youtube channel, so you can see it there with some English commentary from me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9paJ_Gz0_Q