Modding Union

[en] Edain Mod => [Edain] Discussion and Feedback => Thema gestartet von: Azogfan03215 am 25. Dez 2022, 09:22

Titel: Vanilla voice lines vs. Movie lines
Beitrag von: Azogfan03215 am 25. Dez 2022, 09:22
So, for some time, I've noticed some characters in Edain primarily speak in dialogue cut from the Peter Jackson film series. I personally think these lines are said at inappropriate times, have background noise that needs to be edited out, and are very repetitive. I think the best approach to fixing this dilemma is to Mix in the original game voice lines (When it can work) Like for example Aragorn can have both vanilla lines, and film lines. Since I feel the actor did a good enough job sounding like Vigo Mortensen. Can potentially go far as to include lines from older lord of the ring's games (As long as there is no copyright). For example, John Rhys Davies supplied his voice for multiple games of the series like Aragorn's quest, and LOTR the third age. But I want to know if people feel this part of Edain needs to change, or it should remain the same?     
Titel: Re: Vanilla voice lines vs. Movie lines
Beitrag von: Elendils Cousin 3. Grades am 26. Dez 2022, 11:46
As I said on ModDB, the more precise the list of heroes the better :)
You mentioned Pippin, Elrond and the Mouth of Sauron. Which other heroes are you thinking of?

Titel: Re: Vanilla voice lines vs. Movie lines
Beitrag von: Fíli am 26. Dez 2022, 13:21
I really don’t like the idea. I think the lines from the movies are very appropriate and I don’t see a reason for a change. So I voted no, sorry.