It seems that I and hoho96 made two opposed statements
I think that this discussion rightly fits to the Sounds thread, being it not related to conceptual matters like abilities, models, lore accuracy and other ones of that kind.
But, it's also true that the topic was also starting to go beyond the borders of a sound suggestion, involving also the gameplay and the lore.
So, if this debate really widens too much and turns into a conceptual proposal, (Palland)Raschi can easily start a thread in the Mordor Section as our hoho96 suggested
P.S. Being hoho96 the main English Moderator, and having a flaming sword in his hand, I think that he theoretically has the last word among the other English Moderators (only me, in simple words
)