[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] General Suggestions

Imlardis revamp suggestion

<< < (3/6) > >>

LordDainIronfoot:
It is not about the Heroes it is a global War in which Dwarves helped!It is not about single heroes against Sauron but a war !Leta see Isildur ,Gil Galad and Elendil defeat the whole Armies of Sauron bu themselves!? The Last Alliance is not about a duel between Good Heroes against Sauron but to represent the joined forces of thw free people Dwarves,Elves and Man against a comon and global enemy and it is a fact that Dwarves helped with quite an Army consisted of the Noblest of the Dwarves the Longbeards of Khazad Dum heirs of.Durin and led directly by Durin IV himself! :-)

Walküre:

--- Zitat von: LordDainIronfoot am  7. Aug 2015, 00:40 ---It is not about the Heroes it is a global War in which Dwarves helped!It is not about single heroes against Sauron but a war !Leta see Isildur ,Gil Galad and Elendil defeat the whole Armies of Sauron bu themselves!? The Last Alliance is not about a duel between Good Heroes against Sauron but to represent the joined forces of thw free people Dwarves,Elves and Man against a comon and global enemy and it is a fact that Dwarves helped with quite an Army consisted of the Noblest of the Dwarves the Longbeards of Khazad Dum heirs of.Durin and led directly by Durin IV himself! :-)

--- Ende Zitat ---

But that is the way this spell was conceived, helped also by the cinematographic adaptation  :)

The War of the Last Alliance was indeed wider and destructive, but the final duel with Sauron is definitely, in the lore and in the Tales of Middle Earth, the most crucial and tragic moment.

The Two Númenórean Kingdoms in exile lost their King (Elendil) and his son Anárion; and the Noldor lost their last High King, remnant of a great Glory since the First Age and the Years of the Trees, and they will never regain their past Power.

LordDainIronfoot:
While I see your point I still have to say that all that sis not right for the spell.!If we follow that logic then we should have a Spell where we summon only Elendil ,Gil Galad ,Isildur and Anarion ! :-) No,simply the Last Alliance Spell should represent the global war and the uniting of the free people amd among.those Armies rhere is a great Host of Dwarves and they deserve a place among those Armies in the Spell! :-)

Linhir:
In fact, Anarion shouldn't be included! He dies before the duel with sauron, crushed by rock, during siege. :P

Walküre:

--- Zitat von: Linhir am  7. Aug 2015, 02:02 ---In fact, Anarion shouldn't be included! He dies before the duel with sauron, crushed by rock, during siege. :P

--- Ende Zitat ---

But he took part anyway in the final Siege of Sauron's Dark Fortress, along with the Noldor guided by Gil-galad and his herald Elrond.

As you may know, not only the Dwarves were present in the previous battles of the War, but also troops from Lórien, guided by Amdír, and troops from Mirkwood, guided by Oropher, Thranduil's father.
Do they all have to be included?
I think they don't, lest the spell become OP and a bit confusing, losing its LOTR trilogy's references.
And the cinematographic prologue of LOTR is definitely one of the most famous and iconic elements of this trilogy.

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete