[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Imladris Suggestions

Bilbo, oh Bilbo - What happens to you?

<< < (3/12) > >>

Gandalf The Gray:
i think your ideas are amazing
1+

Adrigabbro:
I don't like the idea of Bilbo fighting at all. I also think your last ability "need for the one ring" doesn't fit into Rivendell theme for Rivendell is the last faction that would seek for the ring.
Your other ideas are very interesting though, especially "teaching of the halflings", "exeprience travellers" and "weaknesses of monsters".

Ealendril der Dunkle:
Remember: Rivendell will have the hobbit farm on the settlements. Maybe there is some way to implement the old Bilbo? Discusse it.

@DrHouse: Some interesting ideas out there. ;)

DrHouse93:

--- Zitat von: Adrigabbro am 27. Okt 2015, 13:07 ---I don't like the idea of Bilbo fighting at all. I also think your last ability "need for the one ring" doesn't fit into Rivendell theme for Rivendell is the last faction that would seek for the ring.
Your other ideas are very interesting though, especially "teaching of the halflings", "exeprience travellers" and "weaknesses of monsters".

--- Ende Zitat ---
That's the point. RIVENDELL is not interested at all on seeking the Ring. That's not the same for Bilbo. He kept it for 60 years, and even when he left it to Frodo, he was very reluctant and unwilling (he also tried to steal it from him later on and asked Frodo what happened to it on his last journey to the Grey Havens). All this facts clearly state that the Ring did have some negative effects on Bilbo (which openly manifest when he's close to it. Maybe the first part of "Need of the One Ring" may be deleted, and just the Ringhero part may be left^^). Also, making him unable to fight at all would make abilities like "Master Burglar" or "Teaching of the Halflings" too risky to me, because if he's intercepted by weak enemy forces he has no choice than escaping, or using his "Master Burglar" skill to hide, but therefore wasting it. Making him able to throw rocks would give him a very small defense capability (enough to survive few and weak units) but not enough to become a mass slayer (just remember the throw rock deals very little damage^^).  Either way, thank you all for your feedback^^

Gandalf The Gray:
well he should not be a scout i know that maybe he can be a supportive hero and only shear his knowledge of monsters and places in meddle earth and give to a hero som bust of attack on certain monsters like trolls and make him run faster and lvl up a unique way i dont know maybe with the farms if you build farms he will lvl up

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete