[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Dwarven Suggestions

New Iron Hills Unique Siege Weapon

<< < (19/29) > >>

korner:
In my opinion, these are 2 totally different questions:

1. Do you want the ballista being implemented?

- no not at all
- yes, as additional unit
- yes, replacing catapult
      - yes, replacing catapult, catapult will be moved to fortress as expansion
- yes, as a summon by a hero
- yes, but only as a castle extension

If we have collected the opinions of the community, it´d then be the second step to clarify, what features it should have.

I´ll explain it as an example if for instance option 2 gets the most votes:

2. Which features should the ballista get?
- do you want it to be special unit against monsters/ siege weapons/ clumped units?
- do you want it specialiced against buildings?
- do you want it specialised against multiple infantry (if possible with chain ammo) with area damage?
maybe more options...

From my point of view, this kind of poll in 2 steps would be more usefull.

LordDainIronfoot:
May be in the first option you should add something like (without Anti Arrow Effect)! :-)

Fredius:
Expanding those options is just overkill. I know what you're saying, but as said there is only a limit of 5 options in polls. Those sub-options, as I call them, are not very related to the poll itself, it's just basic information about what kind of damage the Ballistas deal, and we need to decide about it before we present our product to the German Forums.

Those 3 options can be summarized into something very simple: They are siege weapons with big iron bolts, so they should deal great damage to Buildings. Since the Bolts are so big, they would knock back a small amount of enemy units within the target area, clumped units will receive more damage anyway, and these bolts can be great counters against enemy siege weapons and monsters. Now what do you think of that xD? If anyone disagrees or has other ideas, please elaborate.

korner:
what is exactly the overkill if you do 2 polls after another?

First a poll about "how" to implement it. After a certain time when there is a clear majority for one or two of the options, add in the other poll to decide the special "use" of the ballista.

We are currently discussing about completely different "topics"/ "decisions" at the same time.

Elite KryPtik:
I don't think that splitting this topic into 2 separate threads with 2 separate polls would be healthy. We can discuss what features the ballista has here, in the replies, but the main ballista itself doesn't need 2 polls with 10 choices.

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete