[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Dwarven Suggestions

New Iron Hills Unique Siege Weapon

<< < (20/29) > >>

korner:
I did not propose to make 2 threads with 2 different polls.

I suggested to make 1 poll in this thread about "how" to implement the ballista and leave aside the decision of what "features" it should have for the time being.

Then after 1 week or something we hopefully have a good vote of enough players.

If this is the case, we´d then delete the first poll and start the second poll IN THIS THREAD regarding the vote of the first poll.

Currently we have players who want the ballista replace the catapult and being strong against buildings. Next one wants it to replace catapult, but strong against infantry with area damage. Next one wants ballista as hero summon and strong against monsters and siege.
There are so many different opinions and options, that (in my opinion) it´d be a better vote to do 2 steps after another rather then mixing up the discussion with different "topics".

Elite KryPtik:
I still don't see why this would be better than just discussing those topics down below, thereby keeping a permanent record of all ideas. I have never agreed with deleting polls, I like to keep the votes registered(that sounded political :P) so that people can see who likes what ideas. Sorry but I'm not convinced.

Fredius:
I agree with KryptiK, it's just too much info right now and people can discuss about it themselves without needing a poll to it. In my translation I'll just put in the first post that people can discuss about what kind of damage the Ballistas should give.

korner:

--- Zitat --- it's just too much info right now
--- Ende Zitat ---
agree! this is why I suggest to do 2 steps of voting both witch less to decide, to make the discussion easier.
But if you don´t like it, okay...

--- Zitat ---I have never agreed with deleting polls
--- Ende Zitat ---
freeze it, stop it, call it whatever you want.

Adrigabbro:
I've voted for the ballista summon from a hero because I think it would be unique and very interesting and because Drar could use some new abilities: being able to summon a ballista could be one of them.
Still, I very much like the second choice (add the ballista alongside the current catapult and make it deal high single target damage), regardless of Ered Luin getting, or not, a new siege weapon for balance, for Ered Luin already got an advantage by having more heroes. But if this option gets the lead, I'd like to see the earth shaker a bit more useful.

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete