[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Dwarven Suggestions

New Iron Hills Hero

<< < (2/4) > >>

Elite KryPtik:
I'm afraid you have all misunderstood my intent when I created this thread. I already knew about both of the other hero suggestions, for the chariot hero and Narin, and I have read the majority of the posts on the Narin idea. This idea is separate, I did not say that NO worthy proposals had been offered, I said that nobody has suggested the Captain from the 3rd film yet, which is why I created this thread.

I will try to come up with some ideas that would fit in well with the abilities of the current Iron Hills hero roster without being duplicate or overlapping roles. I will again state however, that I am not as well versed in dwarven lore, my interests in Middle Earth lie with the Men of the West. So if somebody else wants to try and take a crack at coming up with some ability ideas specific to the Iron Hills Captain from the 3rd Hobbit movie, please feel free.

Fine:

--- Zitat von: Elite KryPtik am  8. Feb 2016, 22:30 ---in the form of the captain that shouts the quotes, such as "Tanar! Durin Nur!"

--- Ende Zitat ---

Afaik, he's actually saying "Tanár Durin-ûl" which translates to "Forth, Sons of Durin".

About the main idea of a new hero for Iron Hills, I agree with Melkor that it would be better to wait until version 4.3 arrives.

Walküre:

--- Zitat von: Elite KryPtik am  9. Feb 2016, 09:56 ---I'm afraid you have all misunderstood my intent when I created this thread. I already knew about both of the other hero suggestions, for the chariot hero and Narin, and I have read the majority of the posts on the Narin idea. This idea is separate, I did not say that NO worthy proposals had been offered, I said that nobody has suggested the Captain from the 3rd film yet, which is why I created this thread.

I will try to come up with some ideas that would fit in well with the abilities of the current Iron Hills hero roster without being duplicate or overlapping roles. I will again state however, that I am not as well versed in dwarven lore, my interests in Middle Earth lie with the Men of the West. So if somebody else wants to try and take a crack at coming up with some ability ideas specific to the Iron Hills Captain from the 3rd Hobbit movie, please feel free.


--- Ende Zitat ---

I know that this is theoretically a new proposal, but it also concerns the long-discussed 'new hero' issue in the Iron Hills faction (the background issue of all the other proposals as well).

That's why I wanted to say that the Captain concept you proposed, taking into consideration the current state of the faction, might not have very high chances of being implemented, in my opinion.
The Iron Hills basically need a new Scout Hero (even though the Ram Riders partially make up for this lack), and I would suggest that this could be regarded as the 'right path' to follow.
I don't know precisely the details of this not-already-developed suggestion, but I assume this Captain will be likely to be a Hero Supporter, or be characterised mainly by supporting abilities as his nature suggests.
Therefore, I think it's not necessary to focus on adding another supporting hero, while there could be other more suitable ideas, if one really wants to target exactly this 'new hero' issue.

But, as I wrote, these are only considerations of mine, having followed quite constantly these matters.
You are obviously free to continue and develop your suggestions; I just wanted to point out what could have been the most effective solution to these problematics  ;)

Linhir:
So... maybe new Iron Hills scout could be Bofur (Son of Thorin Oakenshield's brother, not Bofur from the company).

http://lotr.wikia.com/wiki/Frerin

FG15:
I doubt that isn't a fake.
In the article there is no real source at all and every mention of this topic on the internet is exactly a copy of this article (or the other way around).
Also, Frerin was only 40 years old at that time and so basically still a child. (Fili and Kili were about 80 at the time of the Hobbit, and Gimli was too young to come with them, because he was just 60). Also, the article mentions three sons, but only lists two of them. And it would be an unnecessary doubling of names.

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete