[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Tournaments

Ultimate Skill Cup: Discussion and Feedback

<< < (2/3) > >>

Idrial12:
@Sawman

--- Zitat von: Sawman am 16. Aug 2016, 00:24 ---but I was there for the semi finals and the finals, and everyone but you was ready to go we tried to explain to you that no one else wanted to wait a whole other week just to play one match, but I've seen you play and I have played with your replacement Python many times and in my opinion you two are on the same level of skill so I really don't think the game would have gone any different (no offense)

--- Ende Zitat ---

- I was the only one with an important appointment the next morning
- Never heared such a ridiculous argument sorry  xD
idea for the next tournament: you just create the bracket draw and based on Sawmans und Elites opinion a winner will be determined and free beta access for the winner /irony off

And yet you never stated why you did shift the tournament everytime but not for the final I am pretty sure the only one who didn't want to see the real final and therefore did not want to shift it was you Elite.

I received several pns from people who stated it is senseless to argue with you Elite and I totally feel that way. I am desperate and don't know what to do...

It honestly feels like you do not even try bring up serious arguments on this case

what do the others think? How would you feel in my situation?

greetings Idrial  :(

bsarthas:
Really a strange little discussion. i was just a viewer.  i just wanted to see some good matches.  to be honest ordinary replay would be.. better then the stream was..

 the first weekend was  ok.. just one of you three had a really bad mic.. was terrible to listen.

but the smei final and final.. was just  horrible.. the sound was nearly gone  i didnt understand a thing.  and something  ididnt like the screen was just the half and the other half a screensave  something

 to the final situation. kinda like my own chose of words.

i really find the solution you chosed wrong. because the winner of the cup  got beta access? and then you can just give this chance on a final match  to get this beta access ot something random. something just you chose?

not someone who  made their way throw the tournament?

so i can accept little experience and.. maybe the sound problems.

 but with this decision even with a good thoughts in mind.. was just awful wrong
you cant just take something random.
and you cant justify it with.. nobody wanted to wait any longer... yes you can.. but.. it dosnt make it legit .. if your friend had won vs goodfella. maybe out of luck.. or maybe fella had just a bad day..

he had got beta access without even participate in the whole tournament.. except.. hey wait he had a get to final for free ticket


BUuuuuttt to make that clear.. i really love it that we had a english tournament too. i would love to see like it just. in the right way ;)

Darkayah:

--- Zitat ---what do the others think? How would you feel in my situation?

--- Ende Zitat ---

My short answer to this topic:

I think in the worst case the Leader of the tournament could wait one or Two days. Because all of the contestants were there to have fun. It is in other (Fun) tournaments so, too.

But I'm as viewer have to Agree with bsarthas:

The quality and the organization were not really good.
I hope you learn and the next tournament is better than this.

Lord of Mordor:
This appears to be simply an unfortunate situation where both sides have valid points and neither is really at fault. I find it very understandable that the tournament hosts did not want to postpone the finale any further after it had already been delayed several times through circumstances  beyond their control. The effort it takes to organize such a tournament should not be underestimated, especially for people who have never done it before. You won't get everything right the first time, you'll have to make some difficult decisions in the heat of the moment when things go wrong and many things you'll only have learned after having gone through all that once.

That said, Idrial also has a valid grievance here. No matter the circumstances, she was deprived of her chance to compete for a beta after working hard to get into the finale, and she could not have foreseen that the tournament which was originally scheduled for the previous Saturday only would continue until Sunday evening (keep in mind that German time is six hours behind Eastern Standard time, so it was a lot later for her than for some other participants).

We have decided that the best way to resolve this is to make an exception this time and grant two beta prizes, one for Idrial and one for GoodFella. This way, we hope nobody will walk away from the tournament too disappointed. After all, we're always happy to see fans step up and organize events like this and want to do our best to support them and see the scene grow. We hope to see many more tournaments in the future, each one better than the last :)

Fine:

--- Zitat von: Lord of Mordor am 16. Aug 2016, 14:22 ---We have decided that the best way to resolve this is to make an exception this time and grant two beta prizes, one for Idrial and one for GoodFella. This way, we hope nobody will walk away from the tournament too disappointed. After all, we're always happy to see fans step up and organize events like this and want to do our best to support them and see the scene grow. We hope to see many more tournaments in the future, each one better than the last :)

--- Ende Zitat ---

This is probably the best solution to all of this. Great move.

I appreciate the effort done by the players who were in charge of the tournament, it surely was alot of work to pull of. As others have said, if there are more tournaments coming, I'm sure the problems of this one will be avoided next time.

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete