[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Discussion and Feedback

Terrain ideas

<< < (4/4)

Shagrat:
Adamin said: just from nor mention to say that it has never excisted/happened is a Luxurywe can't accomplish (i hope, thats the correct word^^) because than Gondor shouldn't cbe able to Build towers and Walls

TheMostBurning:
This makes no sense.
Imladris has powerful upgrades even though Celebrimbor is dead,it's logical that there must be good upgrades even though the greatest forger is dead.
Bara Dur wasn't built in third age,shouldn't it be built for this reason :D

Adamin:
Did I understood this right, that you suggest, gondorians never ever built stone buildings again but just reused the old numenorean buildings?

So, those buildings never had to be overhauled?

Osgilliath was destroyed some times as I remember. Did the soldiers just lived in the ruins and never rebuild them?

The Rammas Echor was in pretty bad shape in the Third Age. But wasn't there a rebuilding going on, initiated by Denethor?


Or did I missed something? ^^

Shagrat:

--- Zitat von: TheMostBurning am 16. Sep 2010, 22:59 ---Imladris has powerful upgrades even though Celebrimbor is dead,it's logical that there must be good upgrades even though the greatest forger is dead.
Bara Dur wasn't built in third age,shouldn't it be built for this reason :D

--- Ende Zitat ---

i don't think the Elves had only one great smith, maybe they were nowhere mentioned, but maybe they have existed

But the Barad Dur was rebuild in the third age, and that in only 50 years


--- Zitat von: TheMostBurning am 16. Sep 2010, 22:42 ---Exactly what i mean.But gondorians never build any city in the third age,when the numenor kings' descent had already been interrupted. They lived in the cities built by numenoreans in fact.

--- Ende Zitat ---

--- Zitat von: Shagrat am 16. Sep 2010, 22:52 --- because than Gondor shouldn't cbe able to Build towers and Walls

--- Ende Zitat ---

and Gondor shouldn't be able to build any buliding from that Viewpoint

TheMostBurning:
Teorically the first gondorian bastion is Minas Tirith,the fortress is intended to be a "copy" of minas tirith in-game.
Gondorians may have rebuilt some numenor cities,but we can't compare them.Sauron's leader never ordered to built fortified camps,then should mordor have no fortress?This mskes no sense.Bfme shows ALL the forces a faction have,meaning that even though the white tower is in minas tirith you can build towr guards :P
In-game you can't build minas tirith,so you think that gondor shouldn't use numenor walls as they shouldn't be able to build them,according to the lore?It's like saying that Ereinion's summon should be deleted because Ereinion is dead.

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[*] Vorherige Sete