[en] The Prancing Pony > The Lord of the Rings

Lore Corner - Questions and Debates

<< < (14/49) > >>

ThorinsNemesis:
^^Thanks for the reply Adamin, it's nice to hear that our guess may be lore-true  :).
And yeah I'm still wondering, I never lose interest in anything related to Middle-earth  xD.

CragLord:
And here is regular map,
so can you guys just put some red crosses on places where you think they
had those halls? I tried to compare it with old map of Ered Luin from first age because of locations of Nogrod and Belgost, but I don't wanted to point on anything, because I am not sure.

Point on this map please. xD

http://postimg.org/image/gcb9vm4gz/full/

And then just reupload it? :)

Regards,
Crag

ThorinsNemesis:
Ok, I marked the Three possible locations for Thorin's Halls in red. The possible location of Belegost is in blue, and Nogrod's location is in green. All Three places in my opinion are located in the Northern Ered Luin.
Note that in my opinion the northernmost location of Thorin's halls, above the river and at the end of the map, is the most plausible in my opinion  :).

Walküre:
Can I just say that I profoundly and significantly appreciate and like this thread and the relative discussions?  :)

And, Adamin, do not think to 'escape' so easily with Lothlórien and Galadriel, I'm just so busy at the moment that I won't have the time to answer, the current and the next week too, I guess  xD
My response will eventually come anyway, so, be ready for it; lore debates are like 'vital nourishment' for me  :D

P.S. I decided to set this thread sticky, as it's one of the topics that were initially established here by Adamin (if I'm not wrong), and, needless to say, given that the lore is the core of this whole section, it has the legitimate 'supremacy' in hierarchy over the other more specific threads, if we can consider it so.
And, once I am free from these 'boundaries', stay assured that I will have some interesting lore discussions in mind to expose here, at your attention  ;)

CragLord:

--- Zitat von: ThorinsNemesis am  8. Dez 2015, 15:14 ---Ok, I marked the Three possible locations for Thorin's Halls in red. The possible location of Belegost is in blue, and Nogrod's location is in green. All Three places in my opinion are located in the Northern Ered Luin.
Note that in my opinion the northernmost location of Thorin's halls, above the river and at the end of the map, is the most plausible in my opinion  :).



--- Ende Zitat ---

Thanks man. :) This visual contact makes things much more descriptive in my opinion, and enriches discussion. :)
This is really nice topic as Walk have said, its value is great. :)

Kind regards,
Crag

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete