[en] Edain Mod > [Edain] Gondor Suggestions
Gandalf (Arnor)
AulëTheSmith:
Don't worry Walküre I know you didn't make it for purpose :D given that you are a multitasking moderator I cannot blame you if you forgot something occasionally ;)
Coming to the animation, I like some of the animations of Saruman but not all of them seems to fit with Gandalf, at least that's my personal taste. If you combine both the animation of CaH wizards and Saruman I can assure you that choices are not so limited . In fact if the skeletons of the two are similar we can think about creating a unique combination of animation, without creating nothing new ;)
I got your reasoning behind what is in common among the three Istari. I will include some examples of both Cah and Saruman as well as updating the concept with new ideas this night ;)
Ectheldir:
I really think diversifying Arnors Gandalf from Gondors is a good and maybe even needed idea. And I very much like your proposal for him, Aule, and do not have anything to really ad to it.
Also, I think, that Gandalf should lose his sword and fight with his staff only, as that would show the difference in time even more and seems generally a lot more fitting to Gandalf at the time of the war with Angmar.
However, I had to read this:
--- Zitat von: AulëTheSmith am 27. Dez 2017, 23:28 --- Also, take in cosideration that implemeting this concept would mean to renounce to the ring form in Arnor, in favour of Arvedui as the central ring bearer.
--- Ende Zitat ---
Why?! Why would Gandalf have to remain without the ring in this proposal? I always really liked his black form. Not so much from a gameplay, but even more so from an aesthetic perspective. And I always thought tat form even more fitting for Arnors Gandalf (who does not become the white).
So why is it not possible, to retain his ringform? Can't we still keep that?
AulëTheSmith:
--- Zitat von: Ectheldir am 15. Jan 2018, 18:14 ---
I really think diversifying Arnors Gandalf from Gondors is a good and maybe even needed idea. And I very much like your proposal for him, Aule, and do not have anything to really ad to it.
Also, I think, that Gandalf should lose his sword and fight with his staff only, as that would show the difference in time even more and seems generally a lot more fitting to Gandalf at the time of the war with Angmar.
However, I had to read this:
--- Zitat von: AulëTheSmith am 27. Dez 2017, 23:28 --- Also, take in cosideration that implemeting this concept would mean to renounce to the ring form in Arnor, in favour of Arvedui as the central ring bearer.
--- Ende Zitat ---
Why?! Why would Gandalf have to remain without the ring in this proposal? I always really liked his black form. Not so much from a gameplay, but even more so from an aesthetic perspective. And I always thought tat form even more fitting for Arnors Gandalf (who does not become the white).
So why is it not possible, to retain his ringform? Can't we still keep that?
--- Ende Zitat ---
Thank you very much Ectheldir, for forwarding you opinion and replying xD
The abilities of Dark Gandalf are inevitably bonded on The Gondor version . For sure lighting sword, since we are willing to remove Glamdring. It could be kinda strage to see such a change of skillset from normal to ring form. Also it would probably involved a change in the animation too, since the corrupted as his own walk animation, and it is built around Glamdring too. I don't know, in my opinion is not so feasible nor it's fitting.
Anyway, look at at main post of the concept, i updated it :)
Walküre, feel yourself free to change the image and/or description of Emissary of Hope if you want :)
Walküre:
I fancy the icon picture quite a lot. Good choice! It always conveys that adventurous trait of the wizard's character that I'm deeply fond of.
As for the initial part of the own description, I would word it this way: Gandalf journeys through the lands of grief, bearer of hope at the behest of the West. Then, the effects may be kept as they are.
P.S. You have actually inspired me to give life to a poem about the matter, Aulë. Thank you for the hint; I had better not waste time and write it down immediately :D
AulëTheSmith:
--- Zitat von: Walküre am 16. Jan 2018, 00:04 ---I fancy the icon picture quite a lot. Good choice! It always conveys that adventurous trait of the wizard's character that I'm deeply fond of.
As for the initial part of the own description, I would word it this way: Gandalf journeys through the lands of grief, bearer of hope at the behest of the West. Then, the effects may be kept as they are.
P.S. You have actually inspired me to give life to a poem about the matter, Aulë. Thank you for the hint; I had better not waste time and write it down immediately :D
--- Ende Zitat ---
I will change the description Walküre, you are as always very poetic, I couldn't conceive such words by myself I admit it :D I'm glad I inspired your inexhaustible creativity further :) Then hurry up in writing your poem xD
The picture is the beginning of all the adventures, so it is evocative I shall say :)
I will keep updating the very concept, adding more animations and improving it further where necessary :)
Oh , last but not least it's my duty to put a reference to Narya's concept, since also this version should be included in Narya's list. Furthermore, I thought to change something to make Narya's effect particular to this case, not about magic part but about melee attack, which by the way we should discuss more deeply, since we want the staff as only weapon :)
Navigation
[0] Themen-Index
[#] Nächste Seite
[*] Vorherige Sete
Zur normalen Ansicht wechseln