[en] The Prancing Pony > Other

A possible new Evil Men faction

<< < (14/30) > >>

lordoflinks:
I have come up with what I believe is the best compromise for an Evil Men fraction between those who wish for them to be separate and those who wish them to be in the same fraction, taking into account the community's feedback.
You can find it here:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1P6gcEVaor8HkBdzO3EOeDpMsIxbLHbjLiPUB0YBz6A4/edit

My reason for creating another thread is to hopefully create a thread similar to the Dorwinion thread where work on a single concept is being done; rather than the three or four that are floating in the Evil Men thread; and of course I hope this focuses discussion. I ask anything not related to my concept go in the other thread, so this one stays clear.

To those who feel Harad should be a separate fraction I do agree; but such a move would mean it would either have to be a new fraction, removing any chance the lovely Dorwinion concept could be implemented or use a Dwarf like system. The problem with that is that I believe it would mean Harad would have to have the same number of buildings are Rhun, meaning Rhun would either end up not having enough buildings or Harad would have too many, with respect to their portrayals to lore. I say this however, I think Harad works well as an outpost as it allows us to focus on the signature units of Harad, without coming up with standard units, and it represents their tribal nature well. Finally although one may argue it inaccurately portrays the Evil Men as a alliance that never fought each other, this fraction is set during the War of the Ring when they were united under Sauron's banner and there was little to no infighting. I would also like to say Harad, Khand and Umbar are implemented as Outposts, with each one having a unique way of upgrading their outpost.

The name "Men of the Shadow- Servants of Melkor" on the title page of the concept alludes to the fact that all of the Evil Men originally served Melkor, and at least the numenoreans still do.

Walküre:
I understand the reasons why you would like your proposal to have its own reserved space, and I respect them. Just, the main Evil Men thread is supposed to gather all contributions that relate to that topic, and people have therefore voted for one of the options of the official poll.

You don't have to worry for order or comprehension issues, as I can easily modify the entire thread at will, editing comments at the beginning of the thread or even splitting topics from the primary course of the discussion. When the proper time comes, I will reorder everything and bring the thread to the public light of the Edain boards again. Fortunately, nothing gets lost in this forum. Your main concern should only be the one of discussing and developing your own ideas. Leave all the technical aspects to me, as this is my duty  :)

An excessive fragmentation of concepts or proliferation of new topics wouldn't help the other people during the phases of the debate. It's better to follow these guidelines for now.

Lord Aytugar:
DieWalküre

I have heard some rumors about ending ET after MM released. Is this true? Evilmen and Dorwinion factions cancelled?

Fredius:
Where did you get that info?

Walküre:

--- Zitat von: Lord Aytugar am 13. Jan 2017, 16:00 ---DieWalküre

I have heard some rumors about ending ET after MM released. Is this true? Evilmen and Dorwinion factions cancelled?

--- Ende Zitat ---

This is a totally unsubstantiated information. The Edain Team has not revealed anything concerning their plans after the Misty Mountains yet. What made you assume that they want to 'finish' the project in that way?

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete