[en] The Prancing Pony > The Lord of the Rings

Upcoming Middle Earth film? – Possible theorised scripts

<< < (3/9) > >>

Walküre:
That, aminetude, really was what I call like a very intense stream of thoughts.
I understand you well, since I too often do that operation in my mind, always trying to find a stabler and more innovative concept out of my personal vision and knowledge  ;)

Anyway, I was mainly focused on the Silmarillion, as it could be an interesting and plausible choice in case something else of Middle Earth were ever brought to screen again.

I can nonetheless modify a bit the title of this thread, if you want, in order to make it a wider space for possible upcoming films and speculations based on fan-thought scripts  :)

The destiny of this topic is all in your hands, aminetude  xD

VectorMaximus:
I would definitely agree a Silmarillion movie would be awesome (sad it's unlikely) . I would particularly enjoy a movie that deals with the degradation and political infighting in Tirion after Morgoth spreads his lies, ultimately culminating in the Rebellion of the Noldor.

Walküre:
Dealing with all the causes that built up the Noldor's resentment and caused their Exile would be extremely fascinating.

Even though, I believe it would suitably get into a possible plot in the form of each Noldorin Prince/Princess' memories, while they are stable in Beleriand.
For example, Galadriel recalling in Doriath the moment she stood up firmly in front of all the other members of her Royal Family and advocated the 'return to Middle Earth' cause  :)

hoho96:
@aminetude:

--- Zitat ---The white council arrives, they find sauron waiting with his nazgul, and maybe orcs, or guldur' guards ( i imagine them exactly as they look in ET ), they fight sauron lets his servants  divides the white council's forces,  he heads for galadriel, but her friends know she is strong, but even stronger as a healer, saruman or elrond would stand and defend her from sauron, Sauron does some foul magic that weakens them all, Galadriel tries to heal them, she is weakened and forced to use nenya, sauron then know she got the ring of adamant, he uses his control over the rings of power, only to be stopped by the wielders of Vilya and Narya, he then says a fancy line : "i am the lord of the rings, and what is mine i shall have !", he then uses their rings against them, they are all weak and fall into the ground, sauron comes near to galadriel trying to behead her, saruman then comes and show his power of the istari, and his blessing of the valar, sending all the nazgul into hiding , and making suaron crawl back into the darkness, elrond asks what happens, galadriel says: it is saruman unleashed ( like the isengard unleashed thing from Lotr TT), the ring bearers stand and with THE HELP ( DEVICE ) of saruman they banish  Sauron. THE END !
--- Ende Zitat ---
And the Oscar for the best Hobbit fighting scene goes to... *drums* ...aminetude!!!  xD
I would definitely have liked this more than the weird sweaty Galadriel.
Anyway, regarding the topic at hand, a Silmarilion movie(s) are doable (forget the license for a minute), but a Silmarilion movie in a LOTR caliber is definitely NOT doable at all.
From a pure movie critic pov, the time frame and setup is not movie-friendly at all. Due to the long time scale of the story, the development of events and growth of characters will either be too rushed, or too long. Just imagine what would it be like if Boromir's fall to the ring happened right after they left Revindel, or if Boromir didn't have any screen time involving Frodo and the ring until they were on AmonHen.
As I see it, the only story from the first age that actually make sense for a movie is the tale of Beren and Luthien.
Anyway, my personal favorite is a movie about the Fall of Arnor following two close friends from Rhudaur. When the eternal winter comes (i.e the Witch King) one of them chose to join the Witch King and became one of his captains, while the other didn't forsake his people and went to join the Dunedain of Arthadain.
The movie would climax at the battle of Amon Sul where one of them kill the other.
This would make a great standalone movie while at the same time keeps the door open for more sequels (following the war in general, but through the eyes of different characters. For example the second movie can follow a ranger of Cardoline, while the final may follow the last prince of Arthadain).

aminetude:

--- Zitat von: DieWalküre am  7. Mär 2016, 00:58 ---I can nonetheless modify a bit the title of this thread, if you want, in order to make it a wider space for possible upcoming films and speculations based on fan-thought scripts  :)
The destiny of this topic is all in your hands, aminetude  xD

--- Ende Zitat ---
I would definetly be more than glad to have you change the title to make it suitable for this rich content' discussion. I have no idea of the new title, but any Silmarillion friendly title would do the work hahaha, i know you will come up with something great  ;)


--- Zitat von: hoho96 am  7. Mär 2016, 12:36 ---And the Oscar for the best Hobbit fighting scene goes to... *drums* ...aminetude!!!  xD
I would definitely have liked this more than the weird sweaty Galadriel.

--- Ende Zitat ---
Thanks hoho96, that's very nice of you  xD.
And i adored your idea about the two friends, one goes evil and one goes good, i would even say if they were brothers it could make it much more interesting, and the death of one of them, or both ( i imagine after one kills the other, he suicides due to regret and pain ), it would be much more appealing than the Tauriel & Kili ending ( with all my respect to the fans of these two). Just wonderful, really a wonderful and amazing tought  :)

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete